3 Simple Methods for Thickening Cookie Dough

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Everyone enjoys eating cookies every now and again. After all, they are a flexible dessert that can be prepared in a variety of ways.

When working with cookies, you may experiment with a variety of textures and tastes, such as thin and brittle cookies or thick and chewy cookies.

However, before you begin working with the taste and kind of cookie you are preparing, you must consider the recipe and your ability to deal with cookie dough.

Cookie dough, like many other culinary ventures, may be temperamental at times. Even if you utilize the best components, there is always the possibility that something may go wrong.

Nobody likes to think about this occurring, but it is vital to consider the possibility and be prepared for it.

One issue that you may have is that your cookie batter becomes overly runny. This is frequently caused by adding too much liquid, usually milk.

Depending on what you have on hand and how much more liquid has been added, there are a few various approaches you might take to solve this situation.

The First Method: Doubling the Ingredients

The first strategy to examine is the one that will provide the greatest outcomes with the least amount of effort. You will, however, need to know how much more liquid you added.

This approach works best when you add two-thirds of a cup of milk instead of one-third of a cup of milk.

Simply double the quantity of the other ingredients in this manner to ensure that everything works out proportionally in the end. If you added more than twice the quantity of milk to your cookie dough, you should add the number of ingredients according to that amount.

If you used three times as much milk, for example, you would need three times the components.

This approach works by simply increasing the recipe size, which balances out the quantity of additional milk supplied. While this is the simplest solution to remedy the issue of having too much moisture in your cookie dough, it sadly only works if you know how much additional liquid is in the cookie dough.

You may always gamble and add the components depending on how much additional liquid you believe there is, but you risk having too little milk in the dough.

The Second Method: Adding Flour

The second way is to include an ingredient that balances out the quantity of moisture in the cookie dough.

Even if you did not double the quantity of milk in the dough, runny dough is sometimes produced by an excess of liquid. This implies that incorporating an ingredient that counteracts the liquid should result in your cookie dough being thicker than it is now.

Flour is the greatest substance to utilize in this case. It might be difficult to predict how much flour you will need to solve the condition, particularly if you are new to baking.

That being stated, you may always add additional flour if necessary. It is significantly more difficult to fix extra flour than it is to add flour into a dish.

This means you should add the flour gently, stirring it in and checking to see whether the quantity you added enabled the dough to achieve the correct consistency. This may take some time, but it will be well worth the wait for superb cookies.

While you’re adding the additional flour, you should also add a little bit of sugar. Not only will this prevent your cookie dough from tasting overly floury, but the chemical properties of sugar will aid in the baking process when the proper quantity of sugar is used.

When dealing with this approach, you should always use substantially less sugar than flour.

The Third Method: Using the Oven

When you don’t have the option of adding flour or sugar to your dough, this approach is ideal. It is the least effective strategy and requires the most time to deal with. Because of how long it might take, it can be considered a last option in certain ways.

It is also crucial to note that it might somewhat alter the texture of your cookie dough, so proceed with care if you use this approach.

The oven is used to physically dry out the cookie dough, restoring it to the condition it was in before it got too runny. It takes a long time, and there is a risk of drying it out too much, which you should be aware of.

If you choose to use this approach, spread the mixture out somewhat before placing it in the oven to ensure that it cooks up evenly. The dough should next be cooked at a very low temperature to suck out the moisture.

You should also interrupt the operation from time to time to stir the dough so that it warms evenly and does not begin to fry.

There are a few concerns here, the most serious of which being that you may mistakenly begin heating the dough. This will have a significant influence on the texture of your cookies, so use it as a last option to thicken your cookie dough.

However, if you are determined to attain the ideal cookie dough texture and want to fix sloppy cookie dough, this may be the way for you.

Finally, keep in mind that each technique should be used sparingly, otherwise you may wind up with cookie dough that is too dry or too crumbly, generating the opposite difficulties for your cookies.

Remember that it is far simpler to add ingredients to a meal than it is to remove them.


How do I make cookie dough thicker?

Soft – Dough that is “soft” or “runny” may be thickened with one or two teaspoons of flour. This will help prevent your batch from “Spreading” and turning into flat, non-cookie-like puddles when it comes out of the oven.

How do you thicken cookie dough without flour or cornstarch?

The Dough Must Be Chilled

This approach works best with moist and sticky cookie dough (not dough that looks too much like batter). When dough is chilled, the butter and general consistency stiffen and become more solid.

What are three make up methods for cookies?

Make-up Methods

This is the method of preparing the cookie once the dough has been formed. Drop, icebox, bar, sheet, carved out, pressed, rolled, molded, and wafer are a few examples.

What helps runny cookie dough?

The most apparent and simple solution is to add extra fluids. Add a liquid that you’ve previously mixed into your dough very gently, teaspoon by teaspoon. Mix after each spoonful to avoid over-saturation and sloppy dough. Don’t overmix, since this might exacerbate the issue you’re attempting to solve!

How do you firm up cookie dough?

Increase the amount of flour used.

A few teaspoons of cake flour to a runny cookie dough is the easiest and most recommended approach to thicken it. Overmixing will result in a tough cookie dough, so mix it lightly. Hand-knead the excess flour into the cookie mixture before rolling it out.

How do you keep cookies soft and thick?

Put a piece of fresh white bread in the container with the cookies to keep them soft: fresh bread is moist, and that slice will give up its moisture for the greater good: preventing the cookies from drying out. White bread is recommended so that no taste is conveyed to the cookies.

What can you use instead of flour to thicken?

Cornstarch may be used in place of wheat flour at a 1:1 ratio. Because it is a long-lasting thickening, you only need half the quantity of cornstarch to get the same result. Adding cornstarch to a gluten-free recipe is also a terrific method to add softness and texture to baked products while remaining grain-free!

How do you thicken a mixture without cornstarch?

All-Purpose Flour 5 Best Cornstarch Substitutes. Yes, all-purpose flour is a very stable thickener.
Powdered arrowroot. You’re in luck if you have this starch on hand: It has the same thickening power as cornstarch and produces a lovely, sparkly sauce.
Starch from potatoes.
Flour made from rice.
Tapioca Starch is a kind of starch.

How do you thicken baking?

In a small dish, combine equal parts starch and cold liquid and smooth down until a paste forms, forming the slurry. Bring your slurry to a boil in the hot, simmering liquid you want to thicken. Continue whisking and boiling at the same time until there is no longer any flavor of starch.

What is the most common method for preparing cookie dough?

The creaming technique is the most often used mixing method for chocolate chip cookies and many other types of cookies. The technique of creaming butter and sugar together at the initial phase of the mixing procedure gives this method its name.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *