3 Yummy Ways to Thicken Deviled Eggs

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Summer picnics and family gatherings are rife with deviled eggs. You may look forward to eating deviled eggs on particular occasions, or you may like cooking them for gatherings that you host.

Nonetheless, there are situations when individuals encounter difficulties when attempting to prepare these wonderful sweets.

Occasionally your deviled eggs can turn out a touch runny, which can spoil the whole affair. Nobody loves runny deviled eggs, and you don’t want to ruin one of many people’s favorite side dishes.

What can you do to attempt to make your deviled eggs less runny?

Continue reading to learn more about your alternatives for thickening runny deviled eggs. You will have a few options to choose from to ensure that your deviled eggs are delicious.

If you follow the instructions below, your deviled egg mixture should be thick enough every time.

1 – Use Some Instant Mashed Potatoes

If you’re in a hurry and can’t figure out how to thicken the filling for your deviled eggs, you’ll want to use instant mashed potatoes.

This may seem to be a strange concept at first, but it has the potential to work quite effectively. A little amount of instant mashed potatoes may be used to thicken the filling for your deviled eggs, and it can truly rescue the day.

Many people keep instant mashed potatoes in their kitchens, and you’re sure to have some on hand. It’s quite simple to work with, and it doesn’t take much of it to thicken up the filling for your deviled eggs.

Mixing some of these quick mashed potatoes to the filling of your deviled eggs will give it the thicker quality you want, and your side dish will be saved.

The brand of instant mashed potatoes doesn’t really matter, but the taste is important. While some of these products have more unique flavorings, it is best to choose a basic instant mashed potato combination.

Essentially, you don’t want your instant mashed potato mix to conflict with whatever else you’re using.

2 – Try Using Baby Cereal

Another alternative that might work well is to use some baby cereal. Baby cereal may thicken runny deviled eggs significantly more effectively than you may expect.

The only disadvantage is that you may not have any of this on hand unless you have a baby who is presently eating baby cereal on a daily basis.

Of course, you could purchase some at the store if you want, but the quick mashed potato mix approach described above may be more convenient.

Nonetheless, it’s comforting to know that things may all work out and that you have another alternative. If you want to mend those runny deviled eggs, thickening the mixture with baby cereal is a good option.

You also don’t need to use a lot of this baby cereal to thicken things up. It will be preferable to add a small amount at a time until you are completed.

You should be able to acquire the taste you want, and everything should be thick enough to satisfy everyone who arrives to dinner.

3 – Egg Yolks to the Rescue

You will undoubtedly be able to boil additional eggs and employ the egg yolks to assist yourself.

If you’re creating deviled eggs, you probably have a lot of eggs lying around that you can use. Just boil these additional eggs and use the yolks to thicken your deviled eggs concoction.

Most individuals will find this to be the best option when attempting to cure runny deviled eggs. It’s simple to pull off, and it makes the most sense depending on the sort of flavor you desire. It won’t take long to boil your eggs and prepare the yolks for usage.

It’s also worth mentioning that boiled egg whites may be coarsely chopped and mixed in.

If you don’t have enough yolks to thicken your deviled eggs, use part of the egg whites like this instead. It will save you from having to deal with runny deviled eggs, and you will be pleased with the outcome.

Nevertheless, following this procedure might result in the deviled egg mixture being overly thick. If you make a mistake and the mixture becomes too thick, you may thin it down with some lemon juice.

Just use the lemon juice to loosen things up, or add a little warm water at a time, to get things where you want them.

Pay Closer Attention to the Recipe

Paying more attention to the recipe may help you prevent these problems in the first place.

People often make runny deviled eggs because they speed through the process and do not pay careful attention. You may be in a rush and simply want to get things done, so you may make one or two little errors.

This might be as easy as forgetting an ingredient or not adding enough of a certain ingredient while preparing your deviled egg combination. This may easily result in your deviled eggs becoming runny, which you can prevent by being extra careful.

To prevent mistakes, it is advisable to strive to follow your recipe to the letter. If you do things one step at a time, you will be less prone to make mistakes.

Cook everything at the appropriate temperatures and attempt to use the correct ingredients as specified in the recipe each time.

Deviled Eggs Preparation Tips

Making ensuring your deviled eggs are correctly prepared is essential, and you also want to make things as simple as possible.

This is why using zip-top bags to place your filling in the eggs is so sensible. It can make things much neater than they would be otherwise, and it will save you time.

Fill the zip-top bags with the filling using a scoop or a big spoon. After that, you’ll use kitchen scissors to snip one of the zip-top bags’ corners off. You will then be able to effortlessly fill the eggs without spilling anything.

If you need to move your egg filling to another area, you should wait to cut the bags and merely retain the filling in the bags for the time being. This is a useful tip that will assist many people in making the most of their deviled eggs.

Work smarter, and you’ll never have to worry about cooking deviled eggs for a gathering again.

Enjoy Your Deviled Eggs

Now that you know how to mend things, you should be able to enjoy your deviled eggs. This delectable side dish is ready to serve at your next party or dinner.

Even if things are a little sloppy at first, you’ll be able to rectify them in a timely manner.


How can I make my deviled eggs thicker?

If you overdo it and the filling becomes too liquidy, boil up any surplus eggs and use the yolk to thicken the mixture. What, no additional eggs? Pinch a few of boiled whites, finely chop them, and mix them together.

How do you keep deviled eggs from getting watery?

If you aren’t going to consume them right away, store them in a container lined with folded paper towels and keep in the refrigerator. Deviled eggs tend to “sweat” in the fridge, which may leave them mushy after a day or two. The paper towels will absorb the excess moisture and keep them fresh for a much longer period of time!

Can you add flour to deviled eggs?

Mix in the mayo, vinegar, grain mustard, dijon mustard, hot sauce, chives, salt, and pepper until thoroughly mixed. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Coat the egg whites with all-purpose flour, covering all sides evenly.

What happens if you put too much mayo in deviled eggs?

Too much mayo will dramatically overshadow the flavor of the yolk while also ruining the texture. Note that the filling is piped on, and if it’s runny, it’ll be much more difficult to deal with. The Spruce Eats suggests just three to four teaspoons of mayonnaise per six eggs for optimum results.

What makes eggs thicker?

The length of time the shell spends in the shell gland (uterus) and the rate of calcium deposition during shell development affect the thickness of the shell. The thickness of the egg will be reduced if it just spends a brief time in the shell gland.

How do you thicken egg mayonnaise?

If your mayonnaise is too runny or doesn’t set because you used cold ingredients, just add another egg yolk at room temperature.

What causes runny deviled eggs?

The creamy filling of deviled eggs is made using mayonnaise (or occasionally Greek yogurt). Nevertheless, if you use too much of this ingredient, it will not only overshadow the flavor of the filling, but it will also result in a loose, fluid filling that is difficult to pump into the egg white.

How do you fix runny eggs?

Warm a skillet over medium heat.
Cook for 3 minutes, uncovered, with egg(s) (optional spices added at this stage)….
Finally, in the last 1-2 minutes, cover with a lid to assist the whites cook while the yolk remains soft for a “sunny side up” with cooked whites.
Serve right away!

How do you thicken?

Flour is the most widely accessible sauce thickening. If your sauce is too thin, consider adding a slurry (equal parts flour and water whisked together) or beurre manie (equal parts melted butter and flour kneaded together to produce a paste)—both are excellent thickeners for rich and creamy sauces like steak sauce.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *