5 Simple Ways to Thicken Your Fudge

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Fudge is a luxurious and delectable dessert. You want it to be flawless every time you eat it for that reason alone.

That’s why it’s so stressful and disheartening when your fudge isn’t thick enough or has the wrong consistency in any manner.

Fortunately, there are measures you can do throughout the preparation process to ensure that your fudge comes out thick and flawless every time. Let’s have a look at those stages.

1 – Use the Correct Ingredients

5 Simple Ways to Thicken Your Fudge

Every fudge recipe is somewhat different, particularly in terms of the components used. There are many causes for this.

To begin with, baking is a science, and bakers have always enjoyed experimenting with various mixes and approaches. Furthermore, since everyone’s tastes varies, distinct recipes cater to specific preferences.

However, until you have completely perfected the art of fudge creation, you must use the precise components specified in your recipe. Otherwise, you risk unintentionally altering the chemical processes that occur throughout the heating process, resulting in thin or unpleasant fudge.

This restriction also applies to flavoring substances like as cocoa powder or baking chocolate, peanut butter, or even candy bits. The recipe was written with those extra components in mind, and modifying them might have an effect on the result.

2 – Measure Precisely

You must not only use the exact components, but you must also correctly measure them. Even little changes in the component ratio might degrade the hardness of the fudge, particularly if you use too much liquid or not enough sugar.

We highly advise using a food scale instead of measuring cups to measure ingredients. A scale is much more precise than measuring cups; you’ll like using it and may eventually abandon measuring cups completely.

3 – Follow Your Recipe

Again, consistency and following guidelines are key to producing fudge with the desired consistency, texture, and hardness. Whatever your recipe suggests is what you should do until you reach a higher degree of expertise.

Before you begin baking, make sure you have read through the full recipe. After all, mise en place entails not only prepping your materials and equipment, but also ensuring that you can accomplish all of the needed processes properly.

If there are any processes that you do not understand or are unfamiliar with, chances are there is a YouTube video, WikiHow, or some other kind of internet lesson for it. Consider it a chance to learn something new.

Furthermore, ensure that you have enough time to finish all of the processes carefully. If you only have 45 minutes, don’t start baking anything that will take an hour.

4 – Heat it to the Correct Temperature

When it comes to correctly thickening the fudge, one of the most important procedures is heating. The components come together in precise chemical reactions when heated, which is why it is critical to get it correctly.

As a result, we highly advise using a candy thermometer while creating fudge. Without one, it will be almost hard to do it correctly.

The fudge must be heated to a temperature of 235 to 245 degrees Fahrenheit. The temperature range allows for some inaccuracy in the thermometer you use (very few thermometers are completely accurate), which is a relief (you can test the accuracy of your candy thermometer by immersing it in boiling water, where it should read exactly 212 degrees Fahrenheit).

Another fantastic technique for making superb fudge is to not stir it after it has begun to boil. Stirring at this stage may cause the sugar to crystallize, resulting in graininess or other problems.

It’s time to set the fudge now that it’s hot enough. The thickness of the ultimate product is also affected by proper setting (or hardening operations). We’ll get to it later.

5 – Set it Right

The procedure of setting fudge has a significant impact on its thickness and consistency. That is why, although though it is an inactive phase in the fudge-making process, it is critical to do it correctly.

Our first bit of advise for setting is to follow the directions on your recipe. Setting instructions will be specific to each recipe and will be directly related to the fudge’s components.

Having said that, there are several pointers and techniques, as well as general guidelines, that you may follow. For one thing, make sure the fudge has enough time to set; often simply giving it a little additional time will enough.

We suggest storing the fudge in the refrigerator overnight. You can’t overset the fudge, so you’ll know for sure whether the setting caused the issue.

Reduce the amount of times you open the fridge while the fudge is hardening. Every time it is opened, temperature variations occur, which might have a detrimental impact on the texture of the fudge.

Never put fudge in the freezer, and if your refrigerator has temperature variations, don’t place it in the cooler portions where the liquid may freeze.

Finally, consider your environmental circumstances. There shouldn’t be much variation inside the fridge, but if you live in a very hot or humid region, your fudge may take a little longer to set.

Can You Fix Thin Fudge?

The good news is that you can typically cure fudge that hasn’t hardened correctly. Simply return it to the pot and reheat it to the desired temperature using the candy thermometer. To be cautious, you should aim for the upper end of the range this time.

If your fudge did not firm properly or was too thin, try adding a little quantity of powdered sugar to see if that helps. Begin with a teaspoon or two, fully blend, then add more if the melted liquid still seems runny.

If you don’t have powdered sugar or don’t want the fudge to be even sweeter, use cornstarch. Add a spoonful of cornstarch to a tablespoon of water and mix vigorously until the fudge thickens considerably.

Alternatively, use the soft ball technique, which involves dropping a little bit of hot fudge into a cup of cold water. When it’s done, it should form a soft ball that’s flexible yet hard when pressed. This strategy works particularly well if you don’t have a decent candy thermometer.

Enjoy Your Fudge!

Don’t toss away your fudge if it didn’t turn out perfectly. There are several ways to utilize badly hardened fudge without wasting food or the effort you put into creating it.

Our favorite way to enjoy the fudge is as an ice cream topping. The most essential component of baking anything, from fudge to baked Alaska, is to love both the process and the end result!


How do you fix watery fudge?

If your fudge is mushy or liquid, it most likely did not reach a high enough temperature when cooking. Return it to the pot and stir in 1-2 US tbsp (15-30 ml) of 35% fat whipped cream. Stir the fudge while it warms, but only until the chocolate’s sugar has entirely melted.

How do you make homemade fudge firmer?

Make use of powdered sugar. Replace the evaporated milk with powdered sugar and combine your fudge batter. If the fudge is difficult to setting and hardening, the powdered sugar may assist.

Why is my fudge too runny?

The primary cause for this is that your fudge has not achieved the ideal temperature. Your mixture will always be soft if it only hits 110 or 112 degrees Celsius. That is why we suggest purchasing a sugar thermometer. Another reason your fudge isn’t setting is if the liquid-to-sugar ratio is too high.

What makes fudge firm up?

The length of time you boil fudge impacts its hardness directly. Too little time and the water will not evaporate, resulting in soft fudge. Cooking it too long, on the other hand, will result in fudge that is excessively dry and crumbly.

What can I add to fudge to thicken it?

Add a spoonful of cornstarch to a tablespoon of water and mix vigorously until the fudge thickens considerably.

What is the secret to making creamy fudge?

Tips for making great fudge
Cooking should not be stirred. Fudge may be made either on the stovetop or in the microwave.
Prevent crystallization. Sugar crystals may adhere to the edges of the pan during cooking.
Allow to cool before pounding. To make fudge, the sugar must crystallize again after it has been heated.
Mix the ingredients together.

How long does it take fudge to firm?

How Long Should Fudge Be Cooled Before Cutting? The fudge will take two to three hours to solidify. It’s difficult to resist the want to cut into the fudge, but try to wait until it has hardened up before doing so.

Can I remelt fudge?

If your fudge becomes too soft, reheat it and add additional melted chocolate. Just be sure not to overcook the chocolate.

When should I stop beating fudge?

When the fudge has cooled, whip it until it thickens and loses its glossiness. What exactly is this? Just like not stirring was critical throughout the cooking stage, beating is critical now. Stirring regulates the size of the sugar crystals that develop, preventing the fudge from becoming gritty.

How do you rescue fudge that won’t set?

The sugar, butter, and milk combination required to be cooked longer or at a higher temperature in many circumstances. When fudge does not set, this is frequently the cause. You may reheat your fudge mixture by adding a bit more evaporated milk and gradually bringing it back to a boil.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *