7 Simple Ways to Thicken Your Baked Beans

12 Min Read
Rate this post

Baked beans are really appetizing, and many people consume them on a regular basis. If you like baked beans, you may be searching for a reason to prepare them again soon.

Baked beans are a typical side dish during a barbeque, and it simply wouldn’t be right to have any form of grilled cuisine without having baked beans on the side. If you’re preparing baked beans right now, you’re probably striving to get them exactly perfect.

The greatest baked beans should be rich and delicious, as well as thick. If your baked beans look to be on the thin side, that simply will not do.

You may be concerned that you have made a mistake and will not be able to rectify the baked beans in time. Don’t worry, thickening baked beans is feasible if you know what you’re doing.

Continue reading to find out how to thicken baked beans so they taste excellent and have the correct consistency. It will always be simple to get baked burns to come out nicely after you’ve read the information below.

Slow Cookers Sometimes Cause Beans to Turn Out Thin

7 Simple Ways to Thicken Your Baked Beans

People often use slow cookers to create baked beans. Slow cookers may produce excellent baked beans, and many people prefer using them because they make baking baked beans simpler.

Simply place baked beans and seasonings in a slow cooker and let the beans to simmer for many hours. The baked beans should be done by the time you’re ready to eat later in the day.

The issue is that slow cookers are notorious for producing too thin baked beans. This doesnt always occur, but it can happen because the baked beans are being cooked in a way that doesnt allow liquid to be lost during cooking.

This does not have to be a big concern since you can just try several strategies to thicken the beans. If you want to create baked beans in a slow cooker, you don’t have to avoid it since the baked beans may come out little thin.

It will be simpler to return to normalcy if you know how to manage circumstances like these. You may still save time by using a slow cooker, but you should be prepared in case the baked beans are too thin.

1 – Try Using Less Liquid

One of the first things to note is that your beans may seem thin because you used too much liquid. When creating baked beans, it is recommended to avoid adding too much water or stock components, which will result in soupy beans.

Runny beans are the last thing you want to eat during a family barbecue. You may prevent complications like these by using just the quantity of stock components and water that you need.

If the beans are really watery, you may be out of luck. If you add too much water to the beans, it might be difficult to thicken them.

Simply try to remember this in the future. It should assist you avoid having as many issues in the future while creating baked beans.

This isn’t much help if your baked beans are a little too thin right now. Fortunately, there are certain methods for thickening the beans if you make a mistake or two.

2 – Try Simmering the Beans

It will be good to attempt the simplest approach first to see whether it works. By merely leaving the beans to simmer, you may be able to thicken them somewhat.

Return the beans to the oven and continue to cook for a few minutes. Preheat the oven to 430 degrees Fahrenheit and cook the beans for around seven or eight minutes.

Simmering the beans will minimize the quantity of liquid and make them seem thicker. This may also improve the taste of the beans, making them even more delicious than they would have been otherwise.

Those who are preparing baked beans on the stovetop may also simmer the beans. Simply set the beans back on the stove over low heat.

During this time, leave the pot uncovered and stir the beans every now and again. Simply return to observe whether the consistency of the beans has improved in any way.

Eventually, you should notice that the baked beans have thickened quite a bit. If everything works well, this should fix your problems.

3 – You Could Try Creating a Cornstarch Slurry

Cornstarch is a useful item to have on hand when you need to thicken anything. Cornstarch may be used to thicken a variety of sauces, and it will undoubtedly come in handy here.

You want to take the time to make a cornstarch slurry. Simply combine two teaspoons of cornstarch and one cup of lukewarm water.

Some individuals choose not to use water. If you like, you might use part of the liquid from the baked beans instead.

If you do this, you’ll have to wait for the baked bean liquid to cool before making the slurry. Once you’ve decided, it’ll be time to whisk the cornstarch.

If you don’t completely whisk the cornstarch, you’ll end up with a lumpy mess. Continue mixing the cornstarch into the slurry until it is fully dissolved.

When you’re done, add your slurry to the cooked beans. Continue to simmer the beans until they thicken and you are happy with the outcome.

The cornstarch slurry will most likely take at least 10 minutes to thicken the beans. It is normally impossible to predict how long anything will take, but you can keep an eye on the baked beans as they cook.

4 – Flour and Butter Will Also Be an Option

If you don’t have cornstarch in your kitchen right now, you could have some flour. Flour and butter can assist you in thickening baked beans wonderfully.

To be honest, most thickening agents used in circumstances like these will be starch-based. Flour meets the criteria and, in most cases, will work just as well as cornstarch.

When it comes to thickening baked beans with flour, you have a few alternatives. You might try using quick flour or regular all-purpose flour.

Although instant flour works well to thicken baked beans, it has the unintended consequence of making the sauce opaque. Some people may dislike this, but the good news is that you can prevent it by using regular all-purpose flour instead.

Normal flour will work great, however you will have to boil it for a longer length of time. It won’t work as quickly as instant flour, but it will provide the same effects without making the sauce opaque.

5 – Other Starch-Based Thickeners

As previously stated, the thickening agents used to thicken baked beans are often starch-based. This implies that you may tackle the problem using a variety of starch-based substances.

If you don’t want to use cornstarch or flour, you might try using some potato mash or arrowroot starch instead. This should have little effect on the taste of the baked beans, but it will enable the sauce to thicken.

Xanthan gum has even been used to thicken baked beans in the past. You basically just need something that can thicken all of the liquid you’re working with.

It’s absolutely better to look for starch-based thickeners that aren’t too strange. Cornstarch and flour are your best options, although potatoes will do if you must use them.

6 – Mashed Beans Might Help

Another suggestion for dealing with thin beans is to remove a cup of the beans from the pot. Once you’ve gathered a cup of beans, mash them up with a veggie masher.

This shouldn’t take long and will be a simple procedure. Because of the amount of starch in the beans, mashing them will allow them to thicken the sauce.

It will be required to utilize sufficient heat for this to operate well. Return the mashed beans to the saucepan of baked beans and stir the beans over high heat.

Continue to stir the beans until the baked beans have thickened enough. After you’ve finished, set the baked beans aside for 30 minutes to absorb more of the liquid.

This is a tried-and-true way for thickening baked beans, but you will have to give up some beans to make the sauce richer. When the alternative is sloppy beans at your picnic, it’s typically a worthwhile deal to make.

7 – Thick Seasonings Can Make a Difference

Have you considered how various spices could affect the flavor? There are a variety of items that may be added to baked beans to improve their flavor.

Seasonings may be made from a variety of components, and their effects on the baked beans will vary. For example, you may add honey to baked beans to make them a little sweeter.

The honey will not only sweeten the beans, but it will also thicken them. The same may be stated of seasonings like barbecue sauce, golden syrup, and tomato paste.

If you’re concerned that your baked beans are too thin, try adding some spices to help thicken them up. You may not have planned to add barbecue sauce or honey in your baked beans, but that doesn’t mean it won’t be okay now.

This is a straightforward and dependable answer to this sort of situation. In a pinch, try adding spices to appropriately thicken baked beans.

Final Thoughts

It will make your life simpler if you learn how to care for your baked beans. If you know how to repair baked beans that are a little too thin, you’ll never feel the need to start from scratch when things don’t go perfectly the first time.

There are a variety of reasons why baked beans may be a little thin. Using a slow cooker is one of the most prevalent causes that individuals experience nowadays.

Slow cookers are fantastic, and the ease of using one is difficult to surpass. It does, however, cook the baked beans in a manner that prevents moisture from escaping.

Because you used too much liquid, your baked beans may become thin. Sometimes you’ll make a mistake and use too much water at first, or you’ll add too many stock components.

You may improve them by thickening the baked beans with starch-based components or by boiling the beans. Most of the basic components will work nicely to thicken your baked beans again.

Some individuals prefer to produce a simple cornstarch slurry using cornstarch. Others may want to make thin baked beans with flour and butter.

You may also add other starch-based items, such as potatoes, if you want. It’s also a good idea to use some of the beans from the baked bean pot to create a mash that will significantly thicken the sauce.

It is up to you to pick which strategy is ideal for you to employ. All of these methods work well, and you may only need to pick one dependent on the components you have on hand.


How do I make my baked beans thicker?

To thicken beans, use starches.

Simply combine 2 tablespoons cornstarch with 1 cup of water or the liquid from the baked beans (scoop it out into a separate dish and set aside to cool). Pour the slurry into the baked beans dish and mix until the starch has been well integrated.

How do you make bean liquid thicker?

Mix with a thickening agent.

Dissolve a teaspoon or two of cornstarch or all-purpose flour in a tiny quantity of cold water in a separate dish. Pour the slurry into the simmering soup. The soup should thicken as it sits. Add extra cornstarch or flour as required to get the appropriate consistency.

Do homemade baked beans thicken as they cool?

The longer the beans are cooked, the thicker they will get. Keep in mind that they will thicken as they cool. Remove from oven, mix, and set aside for 15-20 minutes before serving.

How long does it take for baked beans to thicken?

Bake for 2 to 3 hours, or until the beans are soft and the sauce has thickened, removing the cover for the final 20-30 minutes to aid in the thickening process. NOTE: If too much liquid evaporates during the cooking process and the beans become dry, add a bit extra of the conserved bean water.

Does brown sugar thicken baked beans?

Condiments like as honey, brown sugar, and molasses may be used to thicken the sauce. These are also nice choices if your beans are too thick.

What makes baked beans better?

How to Make Canned Baked Beans Better
This is maple syrup.
Mustard with a kick.
Sausage made from beef.
Vinegar of cider.

What thickens bean juice?

You may alternatively mix a slurry with 2 tablespoons cornstarch and a cup or two of chilled water or bean juice. Remove the bean juice first and put it aside to cool somewhat.

Does baking soda thicken beans?

Because baking soda lacks cornstarch, it cannot be used as a thickening. Cornstarch is what holds the wet components together, making the mixture smoother and thicker.

Why are my canned beans so watery?

Bean goo isn’t as scary as you may think: it’s usually simply water and salt, coupled with carbohydrates created naturally by the beans.

How to improve baked beans?

How to Prepare Kicked-Up Bacon in canned baked beans.
Worcestershire sauce, spicy brown mustard (yellow mustard may be used).
The brown sugar.
A teaspoon of apple cider vinegar is optional and not shown for tanginess.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *