Buttermilk vs Milk in Cake

6 Min Read
Rate this post

When making a cake from scratch, you already know that you must follow the instructions precisely as written. Many people believe that if a recipe asks for milk or buttermilk, the two components are interchangeable, but is this true?

Can you use milk in place of buttermilk, and vice versa? Before finding the solution, a few factors must be examined.

Learning the Basics

Buttermilk vs Milk in Cake

When a liquid is called for in a cake recipe, it is not only to make the mixing process simpler. Water and milk may seem to be interchangeable, but their fat content and acidity levels are different, and so the texture and even flavor of the finished product may vary.

Here is how the breakdown occurs:

  • When the batter is combined, the fat component offers moisture and hence tenderizes the cake. The cake will be less soft if the fat concentration is low.
  • The acid level of the batter has a direct impact on starch gelation and protein interaction.

If you use a different kind of liquid than what is specified in the recipe, the fats and acidity levels will interact differently. Whole milk contains.Per 8-ounce serving, there is 14% acidity and 9 grams of fat.

In contrast, buttermilk contains 1% acidity and 2.5 grams of fat per 8-ounce drink. This implies that depending on the kind of milk used, the cake will have a distinct flavor and texture when baked.

Let’s Talk Practical Considerations

Buttermilk vs Milk in Cake

In practice, what does all of this mean? It doesn’t imply the cake will taste worse or better with milk instead of buttermilk. It does, however, imply that the flavor and texture will change somewhat.

Cakes produced with whole milk are often darker in color than cakes made with buttermilk. Furthermore, the crumbs of milk-based cakes are a bit coarser.

Cakes prepared with milk might taste a bit blander than cakes made with buttermilk or other additions like sour cream.

Is this to say that cakes prepared with milk rather than buttermilk aren’t as good? No, not always. If the recipe asks for milk, be sure to use full milk rather than skim or low-fat milk, unless the recipe specifies otherwise.

Cakes produced with buttermilk have a lighter texture and finer, more sensitive crumbs than cakes made with full milk. Both buttermilk and milk cakes are quite moist; but, if moisture is your primary concern, the buttermilk vs milk dispute may be decided swiftly.

Other Considerations

So, if you’re debating whether to use milk or buttermilk the next time you make a cake, here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • It’s always advisable to adhere to the recipe’s instructions.
  • Both milk and buttermilk moisten the cake, but the texture and flavor are somewhat different.
  • If a recipe asks for milk, use whole milk unless the recipe specifies otherwise.
  • Buttermilk is extremely tasty in pound cakes.

Also, keep in mind that buttermilk has less fat and more acid than full milk. If this concerns you, you may add a bit additional baking soda to the mixture to ensure the cake isn’t too acidic. Higher acidic levels imply a tangier flavor.

If this is something you like, you may skip the baking soda. If it isn’t, just add a teaspoon or two more than the recipe asks for.

What If You Don’t Have Buttermilk?

Even though the recipe specifies buttermilk, you may not have any on hand. After all, most individuals do not have buttermilk on hand on a daily basis. Don’t worry; all you need to do is put one tablespoon of vinegar in a one-cup measuring cup and fill the rest of the way with milk. Wait 10 minutes before using it like usual buttermilk. People also like 7 Fantastic Ways to Use Up Leftover Angel Food Cake


Can I substitute milk for buttermilk in cake?

You may use any sort of milk, but if your recipe asks for a specific type of buttermilk, such as low fat, it may be advisable to replace a comparable type of milk. Add 1 tablespoon (15 mL) vinegar to a liquid measuring cup to produce 1 cup (240 mL) of buttermilk replacement.

Why use buttermilk instead of milk in baking?

Buttermilk’s acidity aids in the breakdown of lengthy strands of gluten and proteins in baked products. That implies that any dish that includes a dash of buttermilk is somewhat more tender than ones that use ordinary milk or water.

Is it better to bake with buttermilk or regular milk?

Buttermilk has more acid than ordinary milk, which reduces the amount of carbon dioxide generated and thwarts the leavening process required for these recipes. When using buttermilk instead of milk, replace some or all of the baking powder with baking soda to obtain the desired effect.

Is it better to use buttermilk in cakes?

Buttermilk enhances the texture and tenderizes the cake.

When you add buttermilk to baked goods, such as a cake, the texture becomes lighter and more silky smooth. The acid in buttermilk prevents gluten production in a batter, keeping your cakes light and soft.

What does buttermilk do for a cake?

Cake Recipes with Buttermilk

Buttermilk works as a tenderizer. It keeps baked products moist from the outset. Buttermilk has a tart flavor. While its flavor is sometimes overlooked, it protects this vanilla buttermilk cake from being overly sweet and adds a rich, buttery flavor.

Does buttermilk make a difference in baking?

Buttermilk is an essential ingredient in baking. A baker’s dream is acidic milk coupled with baking soda in a recipe. It contributes to the lightness and softness of baked goods. When baking soda is mixed with buttermilk’s lactic acids, the acid neutralizes the metallic taste of sodium carbonate.

Can you use buttermilk instead of milk in box cake mix?

This is a trick I use almost every time I prepare a boxed cake mix. Substitute dairy for water: Replace the water specified on the packaging with dairy. Buttermilk is my fave for that extra tang. Dairy adds fat and helps the cake taste more handmade.

What happens if you substitute buttermilk for regular milk?

Buttermilk from the store is a somewhat sour milk made from a mix of milk and lactic acid. It’s thicker than regular milk and has a faint tang to it. It is not suggested to substitute buttermilk in recipes that call for it with plain milk since the lack of acid will generate a different outcome.

Should I use milk or buttermilk?

What are the health advantages of buttermilk? Buttermilk has less fat and more protein per cup than milk. It also has less calories than milk and is abundant in calcium, vitamin B12, and potassium. It’s also easier to digest than milk since it includes living cultures (similar to yogurt).

Does buttermilk help baked goods rise?

Buttermilk is used in various baked items because it gives a mild tang and enhances the rise when combined with baking soda. We also brine chicken before frying it and use it as a foundation for various other meat marinades.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *