Grainy Buttercream Frosting Repair

7 Min Read
Rate this post

Cake is something that people all around the globe like. There are also cakes for any occasion, from conventional birthday parties to just wishing to consume a sweet treat.

When it comes to baking a cake on your own, you will immediately find that there are several components involved.

On the one hand, you’ll need all of the components to ensure that the majority of the cake comes out well.

It might be even more difficult to get the desired texture for those who are not as used to cooking or as varied with their components. Not to mention the several various cake textures and densities to choose from.

On top of that, when you make a cake, you will also need to work on the icing. Some people feel that the frosting is the simplest component of the cake to create, but this isn’t always the truth, particularly when it comes to homemade icing.

Anybody can create the frosting that comes in the store-bought containers, but it might take some effort to get the desired frosting texture when preparing it from scratch.

If you discover that you are having difficulties with the frosting, the first step in determining what to do next is to determine what sort of frosting you are dealing with.

There are various varieties of frosting, each with its own set of instructions and variances in the recipe. Buttercream frosting is the most prevalent form of icing used on cakes.

One of the numerous issues that might arise while creating buttercream frosting for the first time is that the buttercream frosting becomes grainy. Most of the time, a grainy frosting on a cake is not going to be very nice, so when the frosting comes out this way, it might be rather concerning at first.

But, you may be confident that your gritty frosting does not need to be scraped, and it can be kept.

Before you can attempt to repair your grainy buttercream frosting, you must first determine what went wrong. This implies you’ll need to check up and discover what causes buttercream frosting to turn gritty.

It will be lot simpler to go to the bottom of the issue once you know what it is.

What Causes Grainy Buttercream Frosting?

Buttercream frosting is often intended to be a rich, smooth, and creamy (thus the name) icing that is applied on cakes.

It is a somewhat rich frosting, but due of its smoothness, you won’t have to worry about it overpowering the cake. In fact, it is particularly popular on cakes because the texture of a regular cake complements the creamy texture of buttercream frosting.

That being said, if you notice your buttercream frosting is gritty, you will know straight away that something is wrong. Since this form of frosting is meant to be smooth, any discernible texture other than the norm will be undesirable.

So, what exactly is causing your grainy buttercream frosting?

Most of the time, the problem is the sort of sugar you use in your buttercream icing.

You may be shocked to hear that not all buttercream sugars are the same, but there are significant distinctions, particularly in buttercream. Powdered sugar derived from beet sugar is a nice example of this.

Beet sugar just does not dissolve as quickly in the mixture as typical cane sugar. This means that if you use a powdered sugar that contains beet sugar, the frosting will likely include small microscopic bits of undissolved beet sugar, generating that gritty and grainy feel that no one likes to deal with.

Fixing the Grainy Buttercream

There are many methods for repairing the buttercream frosting, with each option dependent on what is wrong and how much time you have to solve the problem.

The three major options you may attempt are to gently and carefully add some liquid to the buttercream so that you don’t add too much.

Allowing the buttercream to sit for a few hours or overnight softens any leftover sugar that has not melted. Of course, you’ll have to make it again. If you’re in a rush and don’t have time to experiment with liquids, you may add melted chocolate to the buttercream to hide the texture.

Unless you know precisely what you’re doing, you’ll have to take things slowly and cautiously while adding liquid to the buttercream.

Adding liquid to buttercream may easily result in the reverse issue of having frosting that can no longer keep its form and be a proper topping for your cake, which is tough to overcome. You should only add a little amount of liquid at a time, whisk the butter cream, and check the texture.

You can do this if you have time to let the buttercream icing rest out for a little. This will give the sugar clumps from the ineffective sugar enough chance to melt down into smaller bits that will be less obvious when you add it to your cake.

You can normally let the buttercream to sit for a few hours to the whole night. You’ll only need to re-whip it from here and you’ll be set to go.

If you really cannot spare the time, the third option is less of a remedy and more of a means to conceal the flavor.

You may successfully cover the graininess of the buttercream frosting by adding some cooled but melted chocolate to it. This way, you can still apply the buttercream frosting on the cake in a timely manner, but the flavor issue will be less obvious.


What can I do to help my grainy buttercream?

Pour in some milk. A little milk can assist soften the sugar and butter together while you’re mixing, removing any graininess. The milk will make it milky smooth, which is an added plus. Most buttercream frosting recipes will use milk anyhow.

Why won t my buttercream smooth?

5: Cut down on the sweets!

It’s as hard as a rock, and the edges are jagged rather than smooth. Too much sugar in your buttercream not only makes it unbearably sweet and nearly unpalatable, but it also makes it difficult to pipe and just plain unsightly. Reduce the amount of icing sugar you use. Taste it as well.

Can you overbeat buttercream?

Excessive whipping might result in air bubbles in your buttercream frosting. It’s a small issue that won’t affect the flavor or texture, but it may make the dish seem less appealing when decorated. If you don’t want air bubbles in your buttercream frosting, don’t let it whipping indefinitely.

Can you save grainy buttercream?

If it’s gritty, try combining it again to ensure you’ve given the sugar adequate mixing time. If it’s still gritty, you may need to add a bit extra moisture. Allowing the buttercream to rest for a few hours or overnight is another tried and true approach. Then whip it again; this should help.

Can you save curdled buttercream?

Place the bowl over a hot water bath if the buttercream is lumpy or curdled. Keep it there until the frosting has melted all the way around the borders, but the majority of it will still be a cold, solid lump in the middle.

Can you smooth buttercream with water?

Consider having some hot water on hand the next time you’re frosting a cake to help you smooth out the final coat of icing.

Can you smooth buttercream with parchment paper?

Additionally, after using the paper towels, smooth the icing again with parchment or waxed paper for an even smoother finish.

How do you fix buttercream that looks like cottage cheese?

If the buttercream looks like cottage cheese, the butter is too cold and has to be gradually warmed. You may also feel the bowl with your hands. Does it have a cool vibe about it? This is also an indicator that the butter is excessively cold.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *