How Do You Make Cookies That Aren’t Too Cakey?

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Most individuals would agree that there are several cookie varieties available. There are cookies that are thick and chewy, and others that are thin and crunchy.

Some cookies have a firmer texture than others, while some are as soft as butter. With so many various methods to prepare cookies, it is unavoidable that you will produce cookies with the incorrect texture.

That being said, if you recognize you’re producing cookies with the incorrect texture but it continues occurring, it might be a clue that your ingredients aren’t quite right.

After all, the amount and kind of components in your cookies will ultimately determine the texture. Whether you’re searching for thin cookies or soft, chewy cookies, you could be dissatisfied if your cookies come out cakey.

Fortunately, there are steps you may do to avoid this. Before you can begin learning about this, you must first consider the texture and consistency you want.

This will assist you in preparing the ingredients as needed so that you may bake the cookies you’ve always desired.

From there, you’ll want to understand about what causes cookies to have a cakey texture and what you can do to prevent this occurring to you and your cookies in the future.

Creating the Cookies You Want

When you bake cookies, chances are you have an ultimate goal in mind. To attain a better final result, you should understand what is required to make your cookies meet that aim. Cookies are classified into three types: crispy, cakey, and chewy.

Crispy cookies are often thin and brittle, allowing them to snap rather than bend and shatter. Chewy cookies, on the other hand, are slightly flexible and bendable before splitting into two pieces.

Cakey cookies are on the opposite end of the spectrum since they are thicker than chewy cookies but also have a more stiff structure.

More granulated sugar and butter are frequently used to make cookies thinner and crisper. For softer, chewier cookies, use less granulated sugar, slightly more brown sugar, and much less butter. While making cakey cookies, you’ll frequently use less butter and sugar.

This means that if you don’t include enough butter, granulated sugar, and brown sugar in your recipes, there’s a strong chance you’ll wind up with cookies that feel more like a cake than the crispy, chewy cookies you were hoping to produce.

Now that you know a little bit more about what goes into cookie kinds, you can start learning about what produces a cakey cookie and how to avoid creating one when you’re not in the mood for it.

How Do Cookies Become Cakey?

There are many ways for your cookies to accidentally turn into cake bites. The majority of the reasons will be due to the sort of substances utilized, the quantity used, and so on.

Most cookies, for example, need flour. If you use a cake flour mix, you will most likely get a cakier cookie than you would typically get.

In general, using too much flour will result in cakey cookies, so if you are constantly baking cakey cookies, try switching flour kinds or using less flour.

A cakey cookie may also be caused by using too many eggs or using eggs that are much too large. When following a recipe, always use the required quantity of eggs and the recommended size of eggs.

Lastly, in addition to the foregoing, another element that makes cookies cakier than usual is too much milk or too many other liquids that were not asked for in the recipe.

Adhering to the instructions and taking care not to add extraneous ingredients will serve you well when making cookies from a recipe.

You should also keep a tight check on measures, since baking is a temperamental activity, and even slightly off measurements might result in a cakey cookie.

How Can You Fix It?

Sadly, until your cookies are done, it might be difficult to determine whether they are too cakey. Nevertheless, if you discover this early enough, there are a few things you can do to rescue your recipe, converting it into something more like to a cookie than a cake.

For starters, if you are worried about the quality of your cookie mix, bake a test batch of cookies using the dough you are working with. This will provide you with a decent picture of how your cookies are progressing and how they will come out.

If you want your cookies to be thick, you may wish to omit the milk entirely or use just a little quantity of it.

While working with a recipe, ensure that you are using the correct ingredient quantities and that all of your measuring instruments are precise.

Even though it doesn’t seem like much, be sure you don’t use more or less than a recipe calls for and that your measures are near to exact.

If the recipe calls for a certain size egg, it is critical that you use that precise egg size if you want your cookies to have a proper texture.

The next time you cook using a recipe that yielded cakey cookies, hold back anywhere from two tablespoons to a quarter cup of flour, depending on the cakeiness and how much of that you want decreased.

Before you know it, you’ll have the ideal plate of cookies that everyone desires.


What makes a cookie less cakey?

How to Restore Cakey Cookies
Don’t Chill Your Cookies…. Instead of Room Temperature Butter, use Melted Butter.
Reduce the amount of flour used.
Don’t over-beat the butter and sugar.
Mix in the baking soda.
Reduce the amount of baking powder.
After baking, tap the pan on the counter a few times…. Reduce the number of eggs.
More to come…

What makes cookies cakey vs chewy?

For softer, chewier cookies, use less granulated sugar, slightly more brown sugar, and much less butter. While making cakey cookies, you’ll frequently use less butter and sugar.

How do you make cookies fluffy instead of flat?

9 Things to Keep in Mind
Keep it cool and use real butter. Your cookies may be flat due to butter’s low melting point.
Shortening should be used…. Dough should be chilled twice…. Parchment paper or a silicone liner should be used.
Exact measurements…. Use fresh baking soda…. Optional add-ins.
Purchase an Oven Thermometer.
Additional information…•Oct 15, 2016

Why do my cookies look like pancakes?

If the oven is too hot, the fat melts quicker than the cookie can set, resulting in pancake cookies. Always preheat your oven and get a quality oven thermometer. Even modern ovens may be miscalibrated, so double-check the temperature every time you put a pan in the oven.

How do you improve cookie texture?

How can I get the desired cookie texture?
Add melted butter if you want chewy cookies.
Add additional sugar if you want thin, candy-like cookies.
Add extra eggs if you want cakey cookies.
Add baking soda if you like an open, coarse crumb with a craggy top.
Add baking powder if you want a fine, tight crumb with a smooth top.

What is the secret to chewy cookies?

Let the Dough to Rest Resting your cookie dough in the fridge is a hidden baker’s tip. Resting it for at least an hour will assist to evaporate part of the water and boost the sugar content, keeping your cooked cookies chewy.

Why aren’t my cookies flat and chewy?

One of the most typical causes for cookies failing to spread in the oven is that you used too much flour. Cookies depend on the ideal butter-to-flour ratio to spread exactly the correct amount when cooked. By using cup measures, it is quite simple to overmeasure flour.

Does brown sugar make cookies cakey?

The major job of acidic brown sugar in baking soda recipes is to react with sodium bicarbonate and create carbon dioxide, resulting in thick, fluffy, and soft cookies (cakey at first, then crunchy if they continue to bake).

How do I make my cookies chewy instead of crunchy?

Soft Cookie Making Instructions
Mix together the butter and sugar.
Choose a low-protein flour.
Don’t overwork the dough.
Chill the dough.
Increase the proportion of white to brown sugar.
Do not chill the dough.
Smash the dough and smack the pan.
Feb 19, 2021

Why are my cookies too cakey?

Why are my cookies so cakey? Too much leavening (baking powder or baking soda) or too much egg are the two major causes of cakey cookies. If the dough contains too much baking powder or baking soda, the cookies will rise excessively when baked, resulting in a cakier structure.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *