How to Convert Brownie Mix to Cake Mix

8 Min Read
Rate this post

So you’ve decided to create a chocolate cake. You go to the supermarket, grab a box of mix, and drive home, all set to bake, only to discover that you bought brownie mix rather than cake mix. What should I do now?

Going back to the shop would be inconvenient, but you still need to create that cake. Thus, I’m here to assist! Your cake fantasies are not yet dashed!

On a similar issue, make sure to read these brownie box mix improvement ideas.

Is It Possible to Make Cake from Brownie Mix?

Indeed, in a nutshell! To make brownie mix into cake mix, just change the fat, egg, and leavener ratios. We must lower the fat while increasing the eggs and leavener.

Brownie and cake mixes are quite similar (which is why its also easy to turn cake mix into brownies). A box of brownie mix contains sugar, flour, cocoa powder, baking soda or baking powder, and maybe a few more tiny components that are common in packaged dry products.

Cake mix, on the other hand, contains sugar, flour, cocoa powder, baking soda or powder, and a few additional preservatives. Have you noticed anything? The components are same!

True, the amounts may differ somewhat, but the core elements are the same. As a result, we should be able to quickly convert a brownie mix into a cake mix.

Do you only want to create cake-like brownies? To find out how, see my previous post!

Difference Between Cake and Brownie

Brownies, as we all know, are considerably denser than cakes. If you closed your eyes and someone handed you a slice of chocolate cake and a taste of brownie, you’d know which was which only by the texture. Brownies are thick and chewy, while cake is drier and softer in texture.

When making a cake from a brownie mix, you don’t necessarily want the density of a traditional brownie. You probably want something lighter and fluffier.

Therefore we’ll need to make the brownie batter lighter and fluffier in some way. This entails deviating from the directions on the box and forging our own path!

In no time, we’ll be saying goodbye to that chewy brownie texture.

What to Change

There are three major changes that must be made in order to convert brownie mix to cake mix, but the best part is that it isn’t that difficult! Only a few changes to the fat amount, egg quantity, and baking powder, and you’re done.

The directions on the side of the brownie mix box will serve as the foundation for our new cake recipe, but we will make a few changes. Let us investigate more.

The Fat

When comparing brownie mix to cake mix, the first thing that stands out is the amount of fat. Brownie mixes need substantially more fat to be added, which is one of the reasons brownies are more thick than cakes.

Hence, in order to make a brownie mix lighter, we must reduce or replace part of the fat. To put it another way, if you want to save money on oil, this is the way to go.

Applesauce will moisturize in the same manner as oil does, but without the heaviness. So, goodbye, oil, and hello, applesauce.

The Eggs

Adding eggs will also improve the texture of the mixture. When you add one additional egg to your brownie batter, it will become less chewy and more cakey when cooked.

So have those eggs ready, and if the packet of brownie mix says to add one egg, add two. The texture is already becoming more cakey!

You still have lots of choices if you don’t want to utilize eggs!

The Leavener

There is probably already baking powder or baking soda (which are not the same thing) in the brownie mix, but we will need to add extra to make it more cake-like. A teaspoon of baking powder is all that is required to raise the brownies to cake height.

It is far more difficult to bake a brownie than it is to bake a brownie.

Before adding the liquid components, stir the baking powder into the dry elements of the box mix. This ensures that there are no baking powder lumps in your batter.

Do you know how to create brownies without the use of eggs, oil, chocolate, or sugar? Let me to demonstrate!

Time to Bake!

Making brownies and cake follow the same basic guidelines. Typically, the brownie mix box will direct you to bake the brownies at 350 degrees F for around 20 minutes. This is also true for our freshly made cake batter.

To determine whether your brownie cake is done, insert a toothpick or knife into the middle of the cake and see if it comes out cleanly, with no sticky batter attached.

A clean toothpick or knife indicates that the cake is ready to be removed from the oven! Let it to cool before removing it from the pan.

What to Expect

What will your brownie cake look and taste like now that it’s finished? It’ll look and taste just like a luscious chocolate cake!

Although it is true that there is no such thing as a free lunch, it is also true that there is no such thing as a free lunch.

The tweaks we proposed would undoubtedly result in a much more cakey product (no chewy brownie texture here! ), and who doesn’t like a delicious substantial chocolate cake?

I guarantee no one will ever know you used a brownie mix!

Final Thoughts

Finally, the answer to whether or not you can bake chocolate cake using brownie mix is a loud yes. It’s really fairly easy to turn a package of brownie mix into a delicious indulgent chocolate cake.

Since both box mixes include essentially the same components, a brownie mix may be swiftly transformed into a cake mix with the simple tweaks we described.

So, the next time you accidentally bring home a package of brownie mix and realize you actually need to create a cake, don’t panic! You’ll be able to consume cake in no time!

Now that you’re in the mood for baking hacks, check out my piece on hacking a boxed cake mix.


What is the difference between cake and brownie mix?

Is brownie batter the same as cake batter? These two box mixes are almost identical. The quantity of leavener used in the mix differs between the two. A cake mix will have more, but a brownie mix will have very little or none.

Why did my brownies turn into a cake?

Excessive Batter Mixing

Overmixing introduces more air into the mixture, resulting in lighter, cake-like brownies rather than thick, rich ones.

What does adding an extra egg to brownie mix do?

If you want to explore, you may add one extra egg yolk. The extra egg yolk adds more fat, resulting in a fudgier brownie.

How do you modify a boxed brownie mix?

How to Improve a Box Brownie Mix
Begin with a nice brownie mix.
Instead of entire eggs, use egg yolks….
Instead of water, use brewed coffee….
Mix in the instant espresso (or instant coffee)….
Add more chocolate.
Increase the taste with pure vanilla extract.
Instead of oil, use melted butter.
More to come…
•Jan 24, 2022

Is cake batter the same as brownie batter?

What is the difference between cake and brownie mixes? A cake mix will have more leavener to help it rise, but a brownie mix would have very little. Brownie mixtures also include more sugar and chocolate than chocolate cake mixes.

Is brownie and brownie cake the same?

Some may argue that they are both cakes and that there is no discernible difference between the two, but the truth begs to disagree. Cakes are light and fluffy, but brownies are denser and chewier, with a crunchier texture in the tongue. Cakes are light, while brownies are more akin to cookies.

What is the difference between cakey and fudgy brownies?

Cakey brownies are light, moist, and airy, with a somewhat fluffy, cake-like middle, as the name suggests. Fudgy brownies are moist, thick, and gooey, with a texture similar to fudge but not quite as dense.

What makes brownies fudgy instead of cakey?

Cakey brownies have a lower fat-to-flour ratio than fudgy brownies. Hence, in this situation, butter and chocolate, add extra fat. A cakey batch has extra flour and is leavened with baking powder. The quantity of sugar and eggs is the same whether you want it fudgy or cakey.

Why are brownies different from cake?

The primary difference between chocolate cake and brownie is the amount of sugar, butter, and wheat used. Another distinction between cake and brownie is that leavening chemicals, such as baking soda or baking powder, are seldom used in brownies. In addition, brownies have more chocolate than chocolate cakes.

Is it OK to add an extra egg to cake mix?

Boxed cake mixes tend to be lighter in consistency, but if you want a thicker, moister, denser cake, just add an additional egg to the mix. The extra fat in the egg yolk contributes to a more soft, moist, and flavorful cake.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *