How to Determine Whether or Not Your Sourdough Starter Is Bad

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Many individuals take delight in preparing their own bread. There are about 140 distinct types of bread and several methods for making them. Some recipes call for yeast, while others do not; some are spicy, while others are sweet.

If you’ve ever prepared sourdough bread, you’ll know it takes a little additional care.

What Is Sourdough Bread?

Sourdough bread is distinct in that it is prepared without the use of conventional yeast, does not need the use of a bread machine, and may be made without kneading.

This bread is baked using a fermented starter, which gives it a lovely crunchy surface and makes the interior of the bread much simpler to digest.

How Do You Make a Sourdough Starter?

You may buy a sourdough starter online from a store that specializes in flour and other baking supplies, utilize one that was given to you, or build your own from scratch.

Be aware that this is not a fix-it-and-forget-it method; this starter becomes a living yeast that must be nourished in order to survive.

2 cup of cold water. You may easily manufacture your own sourdough starter using wheat and water. 1 cup whole wheat flour or unbleached all-purpose flour in a clean 1-quart glass container

This mixture should be well mixed so that no flour is dry. Wrap the bowl with plastic wrap or a clean kitchen towel. The starting must be kept in a warm place (about 70 degrees) for the following 24 hours.

2 cup of cold water. The following day, you will not notice much of a difference, but you will need to remove and discard half of your starting, which is around a half-cup. Now, add a cup of unbleached all-purpose flour and 1 teaspoon of salt to the remaining starting.

Repeat the previous instructions, then cover the bowl and let it at room temperature for another 24 hours.

The next day will be the third day of your starter, and it will begin to show indications of activity. The starter will have grown, have a distinct scent, and will be boiling.

Remove 2 cup of the beginning from the basin and discard the remainder. From today, you will feed your starting twice a day. Space out each feeding so that it is equally spaced. Take a 1

2 cup water. Cover and let aside for another 12 hours before repeating this process. 2 cup back into the bowl, along with 1 cup unbleached all-purpose flour Insert the 1

Repeat the same instructions on the next two days, day 4 and day 5. You will soon see that the starter has doubled in size, is incredibly bubbly, and you will be able to smell the scent.

You’ll keep feeding your sourdough starter until it’s ready to use in your recipe. You will then give it one more feeding before removing what you need to bake your starter to make your wonderful sourdough bread.

There are several ways to make a sourdough starter, so if you commit to this sort of baking, you will have lots of opportunities to experiment with different tastes.

How Can You Tell if Your Sourdough Starter is Bad?

It will take anything from a week to ten days to make your own sourdough starter from scratch.

How and when can you tell if your sourdough starter is ruined after spending so much effort generating it? You don’t want to wait until you’re ready to bake your bread to find you won’t get the desired outcomes.

Fortunately, once your starting has completely evolved, you won’t have to worry. It’s getting there that will grab your attention.

These are some examples of how your starter might be affected:

  1. The yeast will die if your beginning becomes too hot. You should maintain your starter at roughly 70 degrees Fahrenheit. Several folks placed their starter in the oven to warm it up but forgot to remove it before turning on the oven.
  2. Be careful to check on your starter on a frequent basis since it might grow mold or germs that aren’t good for your bread. Toss away your starter if it displays signs of mold that are pink or orange in color.
  3. As your starter develops, you may see a liquid on top known as hooch. If the starter is not fed on a regular basis, this liquid appears when the yeast starts to ferment. The hooch may change colors and still be safe, but if you see a streak of orange, remove the starter and start again.
  4. Don’t be concerned if you don’t observe much activity, such as bubbles, for a few days after you start your starter. You could even notice bubbles one day but not the next. Don’t worry too much, but keep feeding your starting and they should return in a few days.

The best way to make an excellent sourdough starter is to:

  • Feed your starting on a daily basis at the same times.
  • Maintain a temperature of roughly 70 degrees. Any fluctuation that causes the temperature to be too hot or too cold might kill your starting.
  • Feed your starting in the precise amounts suggested. A faulty beginning will result from using too much or too little flour or water.
  • Although you may stir your beginning with a metal spoon, you should not use anything composed of aluminum or copper.

You will be able to make a wonderful and unique bread using a sourdough starter. Your attention and time will be rewarded, and you will be hooked.

After you’ve gotten into this form of baking, you should look for web sites that give starting variants, as well as recommendations on how to keep your next starter and how to make use of pieces you’re intended to discard.

If you bake bread in abundance, be sure to check out these suggestions for what to do with the leftover bread.


What does bad sourdough starter smell like?

Your starter may smell awful for the first several weeks as the bacteria and yeast colonies establish themselves. And I’m not just being sarcastic. It may smell like anything from dirty workout socks to vomit to pretty much anything in between.

How do you know your sourdough starter is bad?

Symptoms of a Failed Sourdough Starter

If your starter has mold spreading throughout it (not just on top), smells extremely bad (not just really sour), or develops an unusual color (not just gray, which is okay), it may be time to start anew.

What happens if you use bad sourdough starter?

Mold consumption may cause a variety of ailments, including respiratory disorders. Mold is not something you want to play with! You would never eat uncooked, moldy sourdough starter. Baking using moldy or rotten sourdough starter, on the other hand, may make you quite unwell.

How long does a sourdough starter last?

A fridge-stored starting may be fed once a week. If you want to use it often, you may keep it for up to two months without feeding. Remove the starting from the fridge for a few hours before using it again, then feed it every 12 hours for 36 hours before making bread with it.

Can sourdough starter go bad in the fridge?

If your beginning has been in the fridge for longer than 6 months, it is most certainly in poor condition. It may have a covering of black or dark purple hooch on top and will stink horribly. Yet, as long as there is no mold present, the sourdough starter may be readily revived.

How do you revive a sourdough starter?

4 cup (2 ounces) water twice day (every 12 hours) and leave it at room temperature, wrapped with plastic wrap. 12 cup (2 14 cup (2 ounces) starter with 1 cup all-purpose flour Thankfully, a little tender loving care is generally enough to bring an ailing starter back to life. NOW DO THE FOLLOWING: Feed 1

What does a dead sourdough starter look like?

Characteristics of a neglected, unfed sourdough starter. When a sourdough starter is not maintained or fed for an extended period of time, a layer of black liquid known as hooch forms. Hooch is an acidic alcohol-like fermentation byproduct.

Can bad bacteria grow in sourdough starter?

The acidic environment of sourdough starter makes it resistant to bad bugs. The lactic acid released as a byproduct of the starting creates an extremely acidic environment in the sourdough starter. Because of the acidic atmosphere, dangerous germs cannot grow, making sourdough bread relatively harmless.

Does sourdough starter go bad if you don’t feed it?

The sourdough starter begins to smell like alcohol if it is not fed often enough. You may also notice that the beginning loses its brightness and does not become as effervescent and energetic after a feeding. Don’t worry, you can always regain the starting.

How old is the oldest sourdough starter?

The earliest known sourdough starter is said to have come from clay jars discovered in Egypt. Seamus Blackley used yeast extracted from 4500 year old clay pots to produce a loaf of sourdough bread. Go here to learn more about this 4500-year-old sourdough starter.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *