How to Reduce the Sugar Content in Frosting (Buttercream, Cream Cheese, & More)

9 Min Read
Rate this post

Frosting is delightful, but since it is so sweet, it might be difficult to consume. As a result, many people strive to figure out how to make frosting less sweet. It might be overwhelming, and the combination of butter and sugar isn’t for everyone.

Thankfully, there are a few easy strategies for making frosting less sugary.

What Is Frosting Made of?

Frosting is the thick and creamy covering that is applied to the exterior of a cake, cupcakes, or cookies. It has a thick and fluffy covering and tastes like sweet butter. It comes in a variety of hues and is creamy and delicious. In this sense, it varies from icing.

Icing is more of a thin, sugary coating that hardens as it cools, while frosting stays creamy and fluffy until consumed.

Depending on the kind of frosting, it is created using sugar, butter, egg whites, cream cheese, or flavoring. You may use standard chocolate or vanilla frosting, but there are many additional options, such as buttercream or cream cheese.

Many are still curious about how to make it less sweet.

How to Make Buttercream Frosting Less Sweet

Adding salt to the frosting is one method to make it less sweet. This is a simple technique to balance the quantity of sugar in the frosting without drastically modifying the recipe.

It will still taste sweet, but there will be enough balance that you can consume it without significantly altering the composition or flavor.

While making the frosting, instead of adding salt, use salted butter. This simplifies the answer even further.

Another approach to reduce the sweetness of buttercream frosting is to add some lemon juice to it. You must be careful not to add too much lemon juice or the mixture may become excessively sour.

For every four cups of powdered sugar in your recipe, add 1.8 teaspoon of salt and one teaspoon of lemon juice. This is the ideal combination; just make sure it complements the taste of your cake.

You may also create a blended frosting by combining cream cheese and buttercream. If your recipe asks for one stick of butter, use four ounces of cream cheese instead. This dilutes the recipe and makes it less sweet.

Since buttercream is basically a fat with sugar, you may reduce the sugar amount by adding other forms of fat, such as heavy cream or shortening.

How to Make Prepackaged Frosting Less Sweet

Many individuals buy readymade frosting instead of creating their own. The major criticism is that these frostings are very sugary.

Fortunately, removing some of the sweetness is a straightforward process. A fine cake may be spoiled by too sugary icing, particularly as it commonly goes between layers.

To begin, remove the frosting from the container and place it in a microwave-safe bowl. Microwave for approximately 15 seconds, then add a teaspoon of salt and a teaspoon of vanilla essence.

Refrigerate it for approximately an hour after thoroughly stirring it. When you attempt this procedure, you will be shocked at how much sweetness you can pull out of it.

How to Make Chocolate Frosting Less Sweet

Chocolate frosting is great when it isn’t excessively sweet, but it may be overpowering when it is. There are a few things you can do to make it less sweet.

Adding additional cocoa to the recipe is one method to do this. This will deepen the taste while decreasing the sweetness.

Sour cream may also be included into the chocolate frosting. When you attempt this procedure, you may determine the degree of sweetness that you want.

You may also make chocolate frosting using melted chocolate and heavy cream. As a result, the chocolate will be more of a flavor than an overpowering sweet taste.

The sweetness of your chocolate frosting will be determined by the kind of chocolate you select. If you want to use melted chocolate in the recipe, you may choose unsweetened, semi-sweet, or sweet chocolate.

Using baking chocolate with the necessary quantity of sugar is your best bet. You may use various strategies to minimize the sweetness, but the chocolate will not add to it.

You may create chocolate frosting using a recipe that mixes cream cheese and chocolate.

It will be creamy and not too sweet. It has a good chocolate taste without being overpowering and detracting from the pleasure of eating your freshly made cake.

How to Make Cream Cheese Frosting Less Sweet

Cream cheese frosting is naturally less sugary. Instead, it’s creamy and tangy. Cream cheese, butter, and powdered sugar are common ingredients.

Next, depending on how you want it to taste, you may add flavorings such as salt, lemon, vanilla, whiskey, and others.

The extra flavors will balance out the sweetness of the powdered sugar, allowing you to personalize the sweetness of your frosting. For example, if your recipe asks for butter, cream cheese, and powdered sugar, you may lessen the sweetness by adding salt and vanilla.

You may also add lemon or a smidgeon of whisky.

What Kind of Sugar Is in Frosting?

People often inquire about the kind of sugar used in frosting. Confectioners sugar, which is granulated sugar that has been crushed into a fine powder, is used in most recipes. It contains starch to keep it from caking up.

The anti-caking component in regular powdered sugar is cornstarch, while tapioca is utilized in organic powdered sugar. This gives the organic variety a richer caramel flavor.

Individuals use powdered sugar to create frosting because it is a simple and fast method. Some often detest the taste of powdered sugar, which may be overpowering in frosting. It may also have a metallic flavor because to the starch.

To offset this taste and make it less sweet, melt your butter and combine it with powdered sugar, salt, and milk in a stainless steel dish. This removes the metallic flavor, and the salt keeps the sweetness at a level that consumers prefer.

How to Make Store Bought Frosting Taste Better

Many individuals purchase store-bought frosting rather than creating their own because they want it to taste better. You may microwave the frosting and then add salt and vanilla to remove some of the sweetness, but it may still taste manufactured.

To store-bought frosting, add heavy whipping cream. It will not only taste better, but it will also be lighter and fluffier, like homemade frosting.

If whipping cream makes it too sweet for you, try cream cheese instead. Let it to come to room temperature before combining it with the store-bought frosting.

You may also enhance the flavor of store-bought frosting by whipping it at home. Take it out and beat the icing with your mixer.

This allows the frosting to expand, making it lighter and fluffier. If you find it excessively sweet, add a bit of salt and some vanilla flavor.

You may experiment with freeze-dried fruit powders depending on the taste of your cake. This will give your frosting taste as well as color. Start with a fourth of a cup and gradually increase until you get the desired taste, color, and consistency.

You may thin down store-bought frosting with water or milk if necessary. Milk will lend a fuller taste without overpowering it, and you may still add salt and vanilla extract.

If you wish to make the consistency fluffier, whisk in a spoonful of confectioners sugar. Continue to add sugar until the appropriate consistency is reached.

This will make it sweeter, so keep that in mind while making it.

Final Thoughts

Cake is great, and so is icing. But, since it is extremely sweet, many people avoid it.

There’s no getting around the reality that frosting’s components make it sweet, and cake is designed to be a sweet treat. To reduce the sweetness of a dish, you might add or modify specific components.

Frosting is as much about texture as it is about sweetness, and by adjusting the ingredients, you can make a light, fluffy frosting with just the right amount of sweetness for your taste buds.

After you’ve tried these many ideas, you’ll discover that you can create the ideal frosting every time, whether you make it from scratch or purchase it prepackaged and adjust it.


How do you reduce the sweetness in cream cheese frosting?

Finally, if you find the cream cheese frosting to be overly sweet or heavy, add a dash of lemon juice. The lemon taste will be subtle, but the acidity will cut through and temper the richness.

Why is my cream cheese frosting too sweet?

When piped, the frosting does not keep its form and is rather fragile. To harden the frosting, bakers prefer to overdo it with powdered sugar. This results in a cloyingly sweet cream cheese icing that isn’t really tasty.

Is cream cheese frosting less sweet than buttercream?

It’s fantastic for decorating! Several cream cheese recipes use less sugar and are much looser as a result; this icing is less sweet than buttercream as-written, but if you want an even less sweet frosting, use less sugar and add to taste (at least two cups).

How do you neutralize sweetness?

The addition of lime juice to your meal might help to balance out the sweetness. If you don’t want the meal to be too tangy, you may add vinegar, such as white wine vinegar, red wine vinegar, or balsamic vinegar.

What can I add to reduce sweetness?

If your food is overly sweet, add some acidity (lemon juice or vinegar) or salt. They will assist to balance out the sugary tastes.

How do you balance the sweetness of American buttercream?

This frosting is flavored with vanilla extract and salt. You may use whatever extract you choose, but adding salt balances out the richness of the sugars and gives a more well-rounded frosting flavor.

How do you neutralize sweetness in a cake?

To balance out the sweetness, ask your tongue what else it wants: salty, bitter, sour, umami, or even hot.
You might try:
Increase the quantity of salt by 18 to 14 teaspoons at a time.
Include a salty component, such as roasted peanuts, crumbled pretzels, or potato chips.
Just before baking, top with flaky salt.
Jan 10, 2018

Which type of buttercream is the least sweet?

While making wheat buttercream isn’t any more complicated than making American buttercream, it’s less sweet and has a more delicate taste. Because of the decreased fat level and the increased structure of the pudding foundation, it also holds up much better in heated conditions.

How do you fix cream cheese frosting?

Grainy icing?
If the frosting is too liquid, chill the whole bowl for 30 minutes before continuing to whip the ingredients until it comes together.
If the frosting is gritty or split, add a teaspoon of milk at a time, beating thoroughly in between.
Curdled on October 8, 2021
How can I repair a split?

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *