Scone vs. Cookie (3 Similarities and 6 Differences)

10 Min Read
5/5 - (1 vote)

The feeling of being enveloped in a warm embrace that we experience from just smelling baked goods is incomparable. They have a very important place in our hearts, particularly the ones on whom we were able to depend when times were tough.

We picked two of those popular sweets that have people wondering about their histories and whether or not they are comparable to one another.

Here, without further ado, is a comparison of scones and cookies that emphasizes all of the similarities and differences between the two baked goods.

Caution: Some of our descriptions may become rather explicit, so we can’t guarantee that you won’t acquire a craving for something sweet if you continue reading this post. So, go ahead and get something to eat, and then come with me!

A Historical Overview of Cookies and Scones

We felt it would be a good idea to begin this essay with informing you about the background of each of the snacks.

Cookies’ Origins

First on the list of countries to which cookies may be traced back is Persia. In the seventh century, not long after sugar became more readily accessible in this area, they gained popularity as a kind of pastry that was eaten at that time.

During that historical period, sugar was not consumed in Europe. In point of fact, it wasn’t widely available until the 16th century; before to that, they depended on honey to provide sweetness to their desserts. Honey was the primary sweetener.

Many of Spain’s recipes and methods of preparing food were brought to other parts of Europe when Muslims conquered the country. From then, cookies traveled to a number of other nations, and finally, they found their way into our hearts!

Scones’ Origins

Scones have their roots in Scotland and may be traced back to the early 1500s.

Oats were the primary component of scones throughout that time period. In addition to that, they would cut the dough into wedges and then bake them in the open air.

Over the course of time, scones gained more and more popularity in the United Kingdom. They did, however, change the formula such that it produced a delicious tea snack in the shape of a spherical ball.

The recipe for scones developed two distinct iterations when it was brought to the United States. To begin, the recipe was altered, and the result was a unique product of the south that came to be known as biscuits.

The second shape is still very much like the sweet scones that are popular in the United Kingdom. Scones are known there as a delicacy. However, there are some subtle alterations to both the components and the overall form.

What Are the Similarities Between Scones and Cookies?

To tell you the truth, cookies and scones don’t really have that lot in common. The two delectable sweets have just three things in common, other than the fact that they are both quite delicious:

1 – Leavening Agent

Cookies and scones are two examples of fast bread pastries that are often eaten. Because they don’t need yeast and don’t take a lot of kneading time, they can be produced very fast, which is reflected in their name.

Instead, leavening chemicals like baking powder and baking soda are used in fast bread. Specifically, the leavening agent is baking powder. If you use any of these agents in a recipe, you will instantly shorten the amount of time the dough needs to rise.

To make scones and cookies, you just add a rising agent, put the mixture in the oven, and the baked goods puff up on their own while they bake.

2 – Main Ingredients

If you compare the components of the two different recipes, you will find that they are, for the most part, the same. Scones and cookies are often made using sugar, flour, eggs, butter, and a rising agent as their primary components.

To tell you the truth, each recipe doesn’t call for too many more components. They have a lot of the same components, but the proportions and combinations are completely different, which makes all the difference.

3 – External appearance

Please, those of you who are knowledgeable about scones, don’t cast judgment on us over this issue!

Nevertheless, a chocolate chip or an American blueberry scone might sometimes be confused for a cookie. This is a common occurrence.

When you look at it more closely, you’ll find that there are a lot of variances. In the next section, we will cover just this, so that you, too, may become an authority on the subject!

What Are the Differences Between Scones and Cookies?

There are six key characteristics to keep in mind when comparing scones to cookies. You are going to get acquainted with each and every one of them:

1 – Sugar Amount

Cookies have a far more sugary flavor than scones do on their own. This is due to the fact that the quantity of sugar called for in a cookie recipe is typically three times that called for in a scone recipe.

As a result, we look forward to putting delicious toppings on our scones.

2 – Butter Content and Consistency

You won’t believe this, but the quality and quantity of butter found in each treat is one of the variables that helps choose the winner.

To begin, the quantity of butter called for in a scone recipe is much more than that of a cookie recipe. Now we get to the meat of the discussion, which is the texture of the butter.

When creating cookies, it is essential to have the butter just melted so that the dough may maintain its softness after it has been chilled. Alternately, using butter that has been refrigerated is essential to producing delicious scones.

In making scones, it’s best to use cold ingredients, especially butter, as much as possible. If you add butter that has been melted to the dough, the flour will probably soak up some of the liquid.

When the fat that contributes to the moistness and airiness of scones is absorbed, the dough suffers a significant degeneration in its primary characteristics. As a result, rather than a flaky and airy scone, you will get something that is more comparable to a cookie.

3 – Leavening Agent Quantity

In contrast to cookies, obviously we want our scones to become nice and fluffy while they’re baking.

This is when the leavening agent comes into play; in comparison to a cookie recipe, a scone recipe calls for a much higher quantity of baking soda or baking powder.

Even more elaborate scone recipes could call for a combination of baking soda and baking powder. As a result, when baked, scones turn out to be tall and airy, while cookies flatten down throughout the baking process to become sticky discs.

4 – Mixing Technique

Both of the doughs are blended together using very distinct procedures.

In order to start making cookies, you must first combine the liquid components, which entails mixing together the egg, vanilla extract, sugar, and softened butter. The next step is to incorporate the dry components into the mixture.

When it comes to combining ingredients for cookies, you have a number of options, including a food processor, an electric mixer, or even just a regular old fork.

In contrast, the process of manufacturing scone dough begins with the combination of the dry components first. After that, you give them a little massage with the cold butter until it has the consistency of sand in your palm.

After that, you add the liquid components, which generally consist of an egg that has been whisked and some milk. All of the mixing must be done by hand when you are at this location.

Again, in order for scone dough to have the ability to rise, we need to ensure that the moisture and air bubbles contained inside it are preserved. Kneading the dough, as opposed to using a whisk or a food processor, allows you to exert that amount of control over the dough.

5 – Dough Texture and Shaping

The consistency of the dough used to make cookies is quite different from that used to make scones.

The vast majority of cookie recipes do not need the use of milk or water. In light of the aforementioned, you should anticipate a dough that is soft but not sticky and can be readily worked through.

In the event that it gets sticky as a result of an excessive amount of moisture, you need to start with a small quantity of flour and gradually increase it until it reaches the desired consistency. After that, a classic cookie is formed into a circle, either by hand or with the use of a cookie cutter.

Because scones are made with milk or, in some circumstances, buttermilk, the dough for these treats should have a little sticky consistency. At this stage in the process, you should under no circumstances add flour to the dough since doing so will cause it to lose its moisture.

Just dust your hands with flour and work the dough on a surface that has been dusted with flour. After that, you may cut it out in either an American wedge form or a British round shape, whichever you like.

6 – Final Taste

When you take a bite out of a cookie, you are greeted with a thick, flat disc that is chewy on the inside and somewhat crunchy on the exterior. Cookies come in a wide variety of shapes and sizes. Of course, there are other kinds of cookies that are supposed to be crispy but not gooey at all.

You may play around with the proportions of the individual ingredients in the cookie recipe to create the ideal texture for the finished product. The cookie’s consistency is influenced by the amount of each component.

When it comes to scones, the bite grows a little bit higher, with layers of flakiness on the inside alternating with layers of crumbliness on the outside.


How is a scone different from a cookie?

A scone is comparable to a biscuit, but it is often sweeter and may include fruit or other flavorings. Scones are prepared in a manner that is similar to that of a biscuit, with the fat being cut into the dry components. Cookies are often shaped like a flat disk of dough that has been sweetened, baked, and topped with a variety of flavorings and ingredients, such as chocolate chips or nuts.

Is a scone a biscuit or a cookie?

Eggs are almost always the solution when it comes down to just one component. While biscuits do not have them, scones do. Aside from that one difference, the procedure and the components are essentially the same.

What makes a scone different?

Katina Talley, proprietor of Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop in Omaha, Nebraska, said that milk and eggs are essential ingredients in the production of scones. “They are less moist, but sweeter, and they may include fruit. Buttermilk is often used in the preparation of biscuits, and eggs are not used. They are generally not sweet and have a flaky, delicate texture.

Is a scone a biscuit or a cake?

A scone is a kind of tiny cake that is often eaten with butter and is produced with flour and fat. During our conversation, we had scones and tea.

Final Thoughts

Our feel-good hormones aren’t picky about whether they get a cookie or a scone for their fix.

However, we are aware of the differences because of a number of other reasons. As a result, we decided to conduct a comparison between cookies and scones.

Despite the fact that both delights are made with the same fundamental components, they develop in distinct paths. Therefore, you shouldn’t have placed as much emphasis on their proximity as you did.

You might also like