Softening Marshmallows (Instead of Throwing Them Away)

9 Min Read
Rate this post

There are certain sweets that are just classics in the realm of desserts. For example, if you’re going camping, most people will pack graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows to create smores while sitting by the fire.

Other popular sweets are pies during the Christmas season and cakes for birthdays.

Nevertheless, there are certain items that most people do not consider to have a shelf life.

These dishes are usually often manufactured almost entirely of sugar, with very little components other than food colors to create color.

But, you may be startled to hear that food may and will alter over time when it gets stale, even though certain foods take a long time to become unhealthy to consume.

Returning to the earlier example of smores, marshmallows are one sort of dessert that most people do not believe can go bad. After all, it’s only sugar, right?

Although this is technically correct, and it may take a long time for marshmallows to go bad, they can go bad if not properly kept or if too much time has elapsed.

That being said, there are techniques to bring the marshmallows back to life, enabling you to utilize them for whatever purpose you planned.

In truth, making your marshmallows useful again is fairly simple, and there are a few various techniques you may try depending on what you have available.

The first step in repairing your marshmallows is to determine if they are stale or just chilly, which means that warming them up with your hands may easily soften them up and restore them to their appropriate consistency.

Recognizing Stale Marshmallows

A bag of stale marshmallows will be dry and somewhat wilted to the touch.

They will still taste the same as fresh marshmallows since staleness has no effect on anything other than texture and the capacity of the marshmallow to melt.

Marshmallows will dry up and lose their moisture content over time.

As they lose their moisture content, they begin to dry out on the inside and outside, with the outer becoming a relatively hard shell opposed to the regular, squishy marshmallow that people are accustomed to.

Another telltale clue that you’re dealing with old marshmallows is that, no matter how hard you try, they don’t melt nearly as well as they should.

Marshmallows are famous for their propensity to melt into a delicious mess, but when they grow stale and dry, they just cook when exposed to fire, rather than melting like they should.

If your marshmallows are relatively solid but begin to soften after you hold them for a few seconds, it’s possible that they were just too cold.

Holding your marshmallows in your hands for a few seconds will tell you if they are chilly or dry and stale.

The majority of cold marshmallows will rapidly warm up and attain their right consistency, however stale marshmallows will stay stale until you act on them.

Fixing Stale Marshmallows

Now that you understand what the problem is and what caused it, you can go on to attempting to resolve it.

One of the numerous characteristics that distinguishes marshmallows from other meals and sweets is that even when they are dry and stale, they are not entirely abandoned. In truth, if you have the necessary materials, they are rather simple to restore to their original form.

There are two basic ways for rehydrating marshmallows and bringing them back from the edge of staleness.

The first way is placing something both fresh and rich in water content in a sealable bag with the marshmallows.

The second way will entail immediately immersing the bag of marshmallows in water.

Both approaches aim to progressively rehydrate the marshmallows so that you don’t damage them by splashing water on them and making a sticky mess for everyone.

Both approaches rely on the marshmallows to absorb water indirectly, whether it is evaporated water from something put in the bag or minute quantities of water that pass through the plastic bag.

For the first approach, you’ll need a big enough sealable plastic bag to hold all of the marshmallows, as well as another fresh foodstuff with a suitable water content. A standard gallon-size bag will enough for a regular amount of marshmallows.

What you add in the bag with the marshmallows will depend on what you have on hand.

A fresh apple slice or two, or a fresh slice of bread, are the two most usual items placed in the bag. Either one will accomplish the job, however keep in mind that mold is a potential for both of these items.

The purpose is not to produce mold, but to rehydrate the marshmallows.

Put the apple slices or bread inside the bag of marshmallows, make sure everything is well wrapped, and leave it on the counter for one or two days.

Check to see whether the marshmallows have achieved the right consistency after the first day.

If they haven’t, you should postpone it until another day.

Allowing the marshmallows to sit out for more than two days increases the probability of mold forming in the bag significantly. Moldy marshmallows are not something anybody wants.

The second way, which you might test, is based on the marshmallows absorbing moisture that has evaporated into the bag. The source of that moisture, though, will be different.

You’ll need a bowl that you can spare for a minute or two for this procedure. This approach is by far the quickest, since it can be accomplished in a matter of minutes.

It may take a little longer to prepare since you will need to wait for the sink’s water to heat up.

Similar with the previous approach, put the dried and stale marshmallows in a sealable bag. From here, start filling a dish or cup with hot tap water (whatever will fit the marshmallow bag best, with space to spare).

After the bowl or cup is filled, insert the marshmallow bag inside and wait approximately one minute.

Because of the nature of marshmallows, they will float to the surface.

This is ineffective for ensuring that they all absorb some water, so use a spatula or something similar to keep the marshmallows under the surface of the water during the minute or two that you are doing this.

Avoid squishing the marshmallows too much; instead, use slight pressure to keep them immersed.

After one minute, remove the marshmallows, open the bag, and check to see whether they are the appropriate consistency.

If they aren’t, put them back in the bag and into the water for another minute.

From here, you may utilize the marshmallows for any reason you like, knowing that they are soft and squishy once again.


Can you soften marshmallows in the microwave?

Making use of the microwave

Marshmallows may also be melted in the microwave. In a large microwave-safe dish, heat them with a couple of teaspoons of water. To ensure that they melt evenly, check them every 10 seconds and mix each time.

What can I do with hard marshmallows?

Dried marshmallows may be regenerated. Put one or two pieces of fresh, moist bread in a resealable plastic bag with the marshmallows. The marshmallows should be soft again after one or two days. Preserve them that way by firmly closing them and freezing them.

How do you keep melted marshmallows from getting hard?

Mix the marshmallows and add additional water if necessary.

Add two additional teaspoons of water after the marshmallows begin to melt. This is done to keep them from drying out.

Can you melt old marshmallows?

Use fresh marshmallows only.

After resting for a time, marshmallows begin to dry out and the exterior becomes solid. Most significantly, they do not melt as easily. Instead of becoming soft and mushy, they dissolve into a single massive glob.

Can you melt marshmallows and reset them?

Yes. Marshmallows may be melted and reshaped into unique forms and textures. Melt marshmallows in a skillet over low heat, stirring regularly until completely melted. Finally, pour the melted mixture onto a silicone or nonstick baking surface to mold the marshmallows into the shape you choose.

What happens when you microwave marshmallows?

The bubbles expand and the marshmallow puffs up because the sugar walls are warm and soft. If the marshmallow puffs up too much, some air bubbles break and it deflates like a bursting balloon. As you remove the marshmallow from the microwave and allow it to cool, the bubbles contract and the sugar hardens again.

How do you make marshmallows soft again?

Put the apple slices or bread inside the bag of marshmallows, make sure everything is well wrapped, and leave it on the counter for one or two days. What exactly is this? Check to see whether the marshmallows have achieved the right consistency after the first day.

What can I do with mini hard marshmallows?

Using Dehydrated Marshmallows:
Sprinkle them over a cup of hot cocoa or put them into your own hot chocolate mix.
These taste just like Lucky Charms marshmallows when mixed into your favorite cereal!
Make cookies or brownies with them, or use them to garnish cakes and cupcakes.
Eat them whole.
More to come…

How do I use old marshmallows?

Using leftover marshmallows into frosting is a terrific way to use them up and save money on baking! Just whisk the marshmallows in a basin over hot water until they melt into fluffy, gooey frosting bliss!

Is there a way to unstick marshmallows?

Just add a little amount of confectioners’ (powdered) sugar or cornstarch into the bag, shut it, and shake, shake, shake until the marshmallows are completely covered. Most of the marshmallows will break apart, but there may be a few that are obstinate and may be carefully pulled apart.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *