The Best Baking Pan for Brownies (Glass vs. Metal)

7 Min Read
Rate this post

Brownies are the quintessential American fudgy confection. The brownie, which is often made of a rich chocolate batter, is soft and gooey on the inside and crispy on the surface.

Brownies may be stuffed with chocolate chips, peanut butter, caramel, and a variety of other delectable fillings. Is it preferable to use a glass or metal baking pan to obtain the ideal brownie bake?

The solution is:

It all comes down to what you’re searching for. Metal pans, which yield a tougher, chewier brownie, heat up rapidly, necessitating greater supervision to avoid overbaking.

Glass pans, on the other hand, distribute heat more evenly, resulting in more uniformly cooked brownies. Depending on your preferences, either may be a fine alternative.

Ways to bake brownies using glass and metal pans

Baking in a glass or metal pan requires a little more work. Here are some pointers to help you make your brownies look scrumptious!

  • Coat your pan with butter or oil. This guarantees that the brownies come out of the pan easily after baking.
  • For extra-sharp brownies, line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Using parchment paper enables the brownies to come out of the pan quickly. It also gives the brownies a more defined edge and a more polished appearance.
  • After removing the brownies from the oven, let them to cool until they are just warm to the touch before cutting. If you don’t wait long enough, the brownies will break apart when you cut them, and if you wait too long, the brownies will be difficult to remove from the pan.

Glass Pan

A glass baking pan is great for making brownies. Why? Glass pans heat up more slowly than metal pans, yet once heated, they become quite hot.

Since brownies have a lengthy cooking time (typically 40 minutes, although this might vary depending on the recipe), you don’t want the pan to become too hot straight away or the brownies will overbake. While using a metal pan, this is a regular occurrence.

Benefits of using a glass pan

  • Heats up gently, reducing the possibility of overbaking the brownies.
  • Heat is distributed uniformly across the pan, resulting in even baking of the brownies.
  • The glassware remains incredibly hot after heated, enabling the brownies to cook quicker.
  • Makes a moist, melt-in-your-mouth brownie.

Drawbacks of using a glass pan

  • There is always the possibility of glassware shattering when temperatures suddenly shift.
  • As the glass slowly warms up, it also retains heat, which increases the danger of overbaking the brownies after they are taken from the oven (to avoid this, use foil to line the pans or cut the brownies soon after baking).

Trying to create brownies but are missing an essential ingredient? Discover how!

Metal Pan

A metal pan, although great for many things, is not ideal for baking brownies. The metal warms up fast, making it difficult to bake anything for an extended period of time without them being overbaked.

Since brownies take a long time to bake, the pan should not be too hot straight away. The metal pan, on the other hand, has sharp edges and produces a more polished brownie.

When shopping for a metal pan for brownies, seek for one that is square and has a nonstick surface.

Benefits of using a metal pan

  • By using a glass baking pan, it is typically simpler to pull the cooked brownies out of the pan neatly.
  • A metal pan would be ideal for brownies with a shorter baking time.
  • This results in a tougher, chewier brownie.

Drawbacks of using a metal pan

  • Since it heats up rapidly, the brownies may overbake.

Alternative pans

When it comes to baking brownies, glass and metal pans are considerably preferable than any other kind of pan, although other pans will suffice.

  • Nonstick pans are simple to use, brownies can be readily withdrawn, and the brownies, in my experience, are wonderfully crispy on the exterior and soft on the inside.
  • tin foil pans These pans are ideal if you need something disposable or to bring to a party. They make a softer brownie and are ideal if you don’t want to bring anything fancy or want to transfer the brownies warm.

While it seems that a glass pan is the apparent victor here, there isn’t much of a difference between baking brownies in glass vs. metal pans. Each have advantages and disadvantages, but both will bake your brownies well.

I like to use metal pans because, although there is a danger of overbaking the brownies, I regularly watch the pan to ensure that this does not occur.

In my experience, baking in metal pans results in a somewhat firmer and chewier brownie than baking in glass pans.

Remember, it is all dependent on your tastes for the consistency of your brownies! Thus, if you’re patient and prepared to keep an eye on your brownies, use a metal pan. Alternatively, a glass pan will provide a mushy but still excellent brownie!

Regardless of the pan you choose, you may be curious about what it takes to produce cake-like brownies.


Do brownies bake better in glass or metal?

Most sweets, such as brownies, cookies, bars, and cakes, work best when baked in a metal dish. The metal transmits heat evenly and effectively, enabling baked items to heat and rise evenly from the edge to the center while cooking at the same pace.

What type of pan is best for cooking brownies?

We prefer a metal baking pan over a glass or ceramic baking pan for traditional brownies. Metal cooks evenly, prevents over-browning, and produces straight edges. Nonstick isn’t essential since you’ll be buttering your baking dish.

Do brownies take longer to bake in glass?

In fact, using glass or ceramic baking pans for some recipes, such as brownies or banana bread, might have negative consequences! This is due to the fact that they take LONGER to transmit heat. Often, the sides overcook before the heat has moved enough to cook through the middle.

Should I bake brownies in glass?

A glass baking pan is great for making brownies. Why? Glass pans heat up more slowly than metal pans, yet once heated, they become quite hot.

What’s the best way to keep brownies from sticking to the pan?

Line your brownie pan with parchment paper.

What is the solution? Prepare your brownie pan by lining it with aluminum foil or parchment paper. This not only simplifies cleaning but also prevents the brownies from adhering to the pan. Win, win, win.

How do you adjust the baking time on a glass pan?

When baking in glass, the conventional recommendation is to reduce the oven temperature by 25°F from what the recipe asks for and bake for up to 10 minutes longer.

Is there a difference in baking time between glass and metal pans?

Keep in mind that if you use a glass dish instead of a metal baking pan, you should lower the baking temperature by 25 degrees and check the meal often since it may be done up to ten minutes early. This is because glass does not heat up as rapidly as metal yet becomes very hot when heated.

In which type of pan will brownies bake the fastest?

Sheet brownie pans are a thinner variant of the traditional pan. They are used to baking thinner brownies considerably faster. For moister-looking brownies and a nicer crust, bake on a sheet pan. Nevertheless, since the pan is thin, it is critical to bake them at a lower temperature than a regular pan.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *