What’s the deal with my dry scones? (3 Common Causes)

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Scones are delicious pastry that go well with hot drinks. These are traditional pastries in the United Kingdom, but they have gained popularity all around the globe.

You could like sharing scones with your friends and family while sipping coffee. Scones go well with a variety of teas.

Some individuals like to purchase their scones from stores or bakeries. If you like, you may even prepare your own scones.

If you recently baked scones for the first time and they came out dry, you’re undoubtedly unhappy. Scones aren’t supposed to be too dry, but they’re also not supposed to be as wet as biscuits.

Something went wrong during the baking process, resulting in a dry scone. What occurred that threw everything off?

Continue reading to find out more about making scones. You will understand why the scones may come out dry, as well as other concerns that may prevent the scones from coming out flawlessly.

1 – Kneading the Dough Too Much

One of the most common causes of scones turning out dry is kneading the dough longer than necessary. Individuals who are inexperienced to preparing pastries may make the error of supposing that kneading the dough more would be beneficial.

Kneading the dough extensively will strengthen the protein connections in the dough. It may cause the scones to be dry and thick.

Scones that are chewy and a little dry are unlikely to appeal to you. This implies you must be cautious while kneading the dough.

After you’ve incorporated the wet ingredients, try to keep the kneading to a minimal. In fact, many scone connoisseurs recommend merely flipping the dough over with a spatula and calling it excellent.

If you’re using an electric mixer, use caution. While mixing the dough for scones, it is quite easy to go overboard, and you will most likely need to pay careful attention owing to how powerful most electric mixers are.

2 – Not Adding the Butter at the Right Time

Failure to add the butter at the proper time may result in the scones becoming dry. If you don’t do things correctly, the gluten will develop barriers that will affect how the scones come out.

While looking for scone recipes, most will advise you to start with the flour and then add the butter. You won’t obtain excellent outcomes if you don’t pay attention and perform things in the incorrect sequence.

Always strive to add components to the mix at the appropriate moments. After adding the butter to the flour, proceed with the rest of the recipe in the sequence listed.

You can’t simply throw everything in a mixing bowl and call it a day. There is a certain sequence of actions that must occur in order for the scones to be delicious.

Too much butter can also cause your scones to come out incorrectly. It will not dry out the scones, but it will render them unrecognizable as scones.

Scones are a distinct form of pastry that are not meant to taste or feel like cookies. When you use much more butter than the recipe calls for, the scones will have cookie-like characteristics.

3 – Other Ingredient Problems

Further issues might arise when the substances are not properly combined. For example, if you don’t use the correct quantity of milk, the result will be quite dry.

Milk is added to the scone dough to help it come together correctly. You must use enough milk to keep the dough from crumbling.

Preferably, you should use enough milk to make the dough sticky and moist. This will guarantee that it has the required flexibility to rise correctly.

Only baking soda or baking powder will allow the dough to rise. It helps to puff up the scones, and you should use the precise quantity specified in the recipe you’re using.

Utilizing too much or too little can entirely destabilize the situation. If your recipe asks for baking soda, you’ll probably need to use buttermilk instead of regular milk.

Baking soda requires acid to react with. Otherwise, it will be unable to perform its functions.

It is also important to remember to add a pinch of sugar. This aids in the browning of the scones in the oven.

Ensure to follow the instructions exactly so that you get everything properly. If you leave out ingredients, the scones will be bland.

It is also vital to accurately measure the components. Take the time to balance the ingredients so that you don’t add too much or too little of anything.

Make every effort to avoid distractions while preparing the dough. People are sometimes distracted by their phones or by chats with individuals in their homes.

If you are not paying attention to what you should be doing, you are more likely to make errors. It is essential to do your best to get the ingredients perfect, or else the scones will not come out properly.

Final Thoughts

Baking scones isn’t difficult, but it’s still quite simple to make errors. Many inexperienced bakers may attempt to prepare scones and end up with dry results.

Dry scones are often unappealing, and you’ll want to avoid making your scones this way. The greatest thing you can do is pay careful attention to the materials you use.

Make sure you’re using the items specified in the recipe. Otherwise, you risk losing out on something important.

It’s also critical to get the measurements right. Take the time to precisely measure everything so that you don’t run into any problems.

It’s important to avoid overworking the dough while kneading it. You want to change it up as much as possible.

If you’re using an electric mixer, it’s critical not to go overboard. It’s easy to overmix scones, and they’ll come out thick and dry as a result.

Ensure to put the components in the correct sequence. Follow the recipe, but begin by incorporating the butter into the flour.

It is feasible to get decent results while preparing scones as long as you pay attention to the tasks at hand. Even if your scones were dry the previous time, you should be able to improve them by following the tips above.

After you’ve mastered the art of baking flawless scones, you’ll probably want to invite some people around. Have some of your closest friends and family around for coffee soon to enjoy your delicious handmade scones.


How do you make scones that are not dry?

The use of buttermilk helps to keep the scones soft. Freezing the scones before to baking ensures that the butter is cold, which produces the airy pockets inside the scones. Adding an egg keeps them rich and soft. You do not have to use the whole quantity of liquid.

Why are my scones dry and hard?

Overworking the dough: If you overwork the dough, your scones will be harsh and chewy instead of the desirable light and crumbly quality. The idea is to massage the dough lightly and just until it barely comes together.

Are scones supposed to be dry?

A scone should not be crumbly like a biscuit.

Of course, there may be layers, but they should be crumbly. A scone is somewhat drier than a biscuit, but not at all dry when done properly. After all, scones are meant to be enjoyed with a hot beverage of your choosing. Add some clotted cream, butter, or jam.

What is the secret to moist scones?

Start with cold ingredients — cold butter, cold eggs, and cold cream — for the flakiest scones. Using cold ingredients, similar to preparing pie crust, keeps the butter from melting before the scones are cooked, allowing it to melt in the oven and produce a super-flaky final product.

Why do you put a tea towel over scones?

Prepare the scones the day before you need them and wrap them in a clean tea towel right out of the oven to trap steam and preserve the scones nice and moist.

What causes heavy texture in scones?

My scones are thick, hefty, and lack volume.

You may have used too little rising agent or handled the dough too much before baking. The oven might have been too cold.

At what temperature should scones be baked?

5. Prepare scones. Scones should be baked in a 425°F oven for 18 to 23 minutes, or until a very light golden brown. Overbaking will result in dried black scones.

Should you chill scones before baking?

Vanessa recommends chilling your cut-out scones before baking to firm up the butter and prevent your scones from sagging as soon as they touch the oven’s heat.

How do you eat a dry scone?

Scones should be eaten with your fingers rather than a fork. For the whole afternoon tea session, there is no need for a fork. It’s a knife and spoon situation. Scones taste best when served warm.

Why are my scones hard after baking?

1 – Overworking the Dough

Working the dough is the most typical reason why individuals make scones that are excessively firm. To get things to come out right, you have to work the dough, but many beginning bakers go crazy.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *