When I cut my fudge, it crumbles.

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Fudge is perhaps one of the tastiest sweet treats available and a timeless favorite that is guaranteed to satisfy everyone from your grandmother to your child. As a consequence, many individuals choose to brew it at home so that it is always accessible.

Even though fudge is wonderful, some people struggle to make it. It takes a lot of time and devotion to get the combination exactly right, and it is not always guaranteed to come out the way you want it to.

One of the most frequent problems that individuals have is that their fudge crumbles. So, how can you prevent it from doing so?

When Your Fudge Crumbles

If you like fudge, you know that the correct consistency is firm and smooth, not crumbly and gritty. If it isn’t, you’re doing something incorrectly. If your fudge is crumbly or lumpy, it has most likely been overdone.

Overcooking your fudge is possible if you forget to keep an eye on it or heat it too hot. Fudge that hasn’t been cooked long enough, on the other hand, will become too soft.

How to Fix it

If your fudge turns out less than stellar, there are still some things you can do to improve it.

If you know that the issue was caused by overcooking, you should first check to ensure that the bottom of the fudge was not scorched. If it has, there isn’t much you can do at this point except discard the batch.

If the fudge isn’t scorched, you can easily re-melt it by scraping it back into a pot and adding slightly under two cups of water. Be cautious not to add too much water and to taste it as you go.

Be aware that adding water might cause the fudge to lose its taste, so proceed with caution. But, if this occurs, you may easily add extra flavour to it.

After stirring in the water over medium heat, raise the temperature until the fudge begins to boil. Make sure you scrape the edges of your pan; otherwise, you will wind up with sugar crystals that will only make your fudge crumblier.

After a few minutes, remove from the fire and set aside to cool.

Other Common Problems

While preparing fudge from scratch, people often complain about it crumbling. Sometimes they notice that their fudge isn’t setting. If this is the case, your fudge most likely did not reach the needed temperature to solidify.

Another explanation for this is if your fudge has too much liquid. While you can always go back and attempt to correct it, you may also leave the fudge as is and pour it over ice cream or cake.

Believe it or not, the weather has a huge impact on how your fudge turns out. The humidity in the air may cause some problems for your fudge. This is because the fudge takes longer to boil in our environment.

Not only that, but if you let it to set, it will get softer.

If you really must make fudge on a wet day, be careful to boil it at a little higher temperature than normal. Use a candy thermometer for the best results. Fudge is really finicky, and your cooking temperature must be correct in order for it to turn out flawlessly.

Another issue that individuals have while cooking fudge is not using the proper pan. Since you will be melting sugar, you will need a pan with tall sides and a sturdy bottom. A non-heavy-duty pan will simply result in your sugar being burned.

Speaking of sugar, there is another cause for concern while creating fudge. As previously stated, grainy fudge is generated by sugar crystallization. To prevent this, just swirl the pot around and use a wet pastry brush to scrape the edges of the pan instead of stirring the fudge.

This not only prevents crystallization of the sugar, but also allows the heat in the saucepan to circulate evenly.

Fudge Recipes

Now that you know how to make fudge, it’s time to put your knowledge to the test. Chocolate chips, sweetened condensed milk, butter, and chopped walnuts are required for this dish. This last component is optional and may easily be replaced with other varieties of nuts.

To begin, place all of your ingredients in a big pot over medium heat and mix them together. Once the components melt, swirl them around to ensure that they are as smooth as possible.

Likewise, scrape the sides and bottom of the pan as often as possible to avoid sticking and crystallization.

When you’ve finished smoothing out your fudge, you can begin preparing it for baking. While putting the fudge down to set, make sure to line the pan with parchment paper. Otherwise, the fudge will cling to the bottom of the pan.

Make sure the parchment paper you’re using is long enough to reach all the way around the pan. If you want to be extra cautious, coat the pan with nonstick cooking spray.

The fudge will then need to be put in the refrigerator for around three hours to set. After it’s finished, pull it out and start slicing. To get the best results, slice the fudge using a heated knife. This prevents crumbling and results in much cleaner slices.

Final Tips

There are a few things to bear in mind throughout the cooking process. For starters, begin monitoring the temperature of your fudge around 10 minutes after you begin cooking, or when it begins to boil. Your fudge must be at 235 degrees F.

Another method for testing the consistency of your fudge is to dribble a little amount of the fudge mixture into a glass of cold water. If it forms a ball, it implies your fudge mixture is ready.

You may always add flavor to your fudge by adding vanilla essence, dried fruits, and other ingredients.

Final Thoughts

Fudge is a delicious delicacy that will satisfy everyone in your household. To make the best fudge, be sure to follow the guidelines in your recipe as closely as possible. Be care to gently mix your fudge until it is smooth.

Otherwise, you will have a gritty consistency that will result in crumbling fudge, which no one likes.


How do you fix crumbly fudge?

Don’t worry if your fudge is grainy; nothing is lost; it just needs a little more effort. Return the gritty fudge to the pan, along with some water and cream, and melt the fudge back down to a liquid before re-boiling it to temperature.

How do you cut fudge without crumbling?

If you’re having trouble cutting or the fudge crumbles, try warming the metal knife (or wheel, or whatever) in hot water between slices. Before cutting, dry the heated knife. Always wipe the cutting object clean between cuts, no matter what you use.

How do you cut fudge smoothly?

How to Make Fudge
Let the fudge to set in the refrigerator for at least 3 hours.
Place the fudge on a level chopping board after removing it from the refrigerator.
Dip a big sharp flat knife in hot water, then fully dry it before cutting one long slice (the heat will help the knife to glide through)
Further information…•September 27, 2019

Should you refrigerate fudge before cutting?

If the fudge is still a bit soft after chilling at room temperature, put it in the refrigerator uncovered for a few minutes to firm it up somewhat before cutting into pieces.

How long to cool fudge before cutting?

How Long Should Fudge Be Cooled Before Cutting? The fudge will take two to three hours to solidify. It’s difficult to resist the want to cut into the fudge, but try to wait until it has hardened up before doing so.

Can you over beat fudge?

Your fudge will be firm, crumbly, and dry. If you begin pounding the fudge before it has completely cooled, it will seize. The necessary smooth, creamy texture will not be obtained. If you overbeat the fudge, it will become rock-hard as it cools.

What is the secret to smooth fudge that is not gritty?

Cooling, not heating, is the secret to excellent, nongrainy fudge. The recipe asks for heating the ingredients to the soft-ball stage, or 234° F, then letting them to cool to 110° F.

Should you refrigerate homemade fudge?

Fudge keeps well at room temperature for 2 to 3 weeks when covered in its original wax paper. NEVER REFRIGERATE your fudge because it will lose moisture and become dry and crumbly.

Why don’t you stir fudge?

Never stir the mixture while it is heating, or the sugar may crystallize again. It is possible that the mixture may seize and become gritty. To see whether the fudge is done, use a candy thermometer or a cold water test.

How long should you beat fudge?

Beat the fudge rapidly with a wooden spoon until it thickens and loses its sheen. This might take anywhere between 5 and 15 minutes. Although beating by hand is the conventional way, an electric mixer may be used if you have one.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *