Why are my muffins strewn? (5 Reasons)

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Baking muffins is a lot of fun, and sharing them with friends and family is always a wonderful idea. Some individuals make muffins as a snack or dessert, while others prepare them to go with certain meals.

If you’re preparing muffins and realize that they’re far more crumbly than you’d like, you could be left scratching your head. What is making your muffins crumbly, and is there anything you can do to cure it?

Continue reading to learn about some of the most prevalent causes of crumbly muffins. If you understand why this is occurring to the muffins, it should be easy to resolve the issues and get everything back on track.

1 – You Measured Things Wrong

The most prevalent cause of crumbly muffins is incorrect measuring. If you don’t measure everything just properly, something will go wrong, and your muffins will be dry and crumbly as a result.

It is more simple to create a measuring inaccuracy than most people think. When you’re in a hurry to make something, it’s easy to misread a recipe or forget to level off a measuring cup.

Slow down and truly take your time measuring ingredients to ensure that your muffins come out the best that they can. It may seem inconvenient to go so slowly while doing this, but it is much preferable than having all of your efforts go to waste.

You should also use good measuring cups that will give you correct quantities of components. Some individuals estimate by using real cups, however this produces less-than-ideal results.

Margarine is the most common component that causes muffins to be dry and crumbly. Since you need precisely the perfect quantity of fat, measuring the margarine incorrectly can ruin your muffins.

2 – You Used Vegetable Oil Spread

Another typical mistake is using vegetable oil spread instead of margarine. Some individuals choose to use vegetable oil spread instead of margarine since it is less fatty.

It actually works against you while baking muffins since you need the fat to guarantee the muffins come out properly. If you choose to utilize vegetable oil spread, the resulting mixture will be deficient in fat.

Margarine has at least 80% fat, and your muffin mix requires at least 70% fat. Using vegetable oil spread will fall well short of the fat requirement that you want, and it may be the cause of your muffins being dry and crumbly.

If you’re going to take the time to prepare muffins, you should go out and get some margarine. Make sure you have all of the ingredients listed in the recipe so that you don’t run into problems by substituting them.

3 – You Used “Diet” Margarine

There are various varieties on the market known as diet margarine or light margarine. You should avoid using them for the same reason you should avoid using vegetable oil spread.

When you purchase diet margarine, it will have much less fat than regular margarine. Lowering the fat level makes it more difficult to get the fat required for your muffin mix.

If you’re attempting to decrease fat from your diet, this sort of margarine could be a decent choice for other foods, but it won’t work for muffins. Remember to use regular margarine with the appropriate fat level for what you’re doing.

4 – Baking Too Long or Baking at the Wrong Temperature

It’s also possible to have problems if you bake muffins for too long or at the incorrect temperature. As you would assume, leaving muffins in the oven for too long may cause them to burn, but you can also bake them for too long and they will get dry.

When muffins are cooked for too long, they might reach a stage where they are not quite burned, but also not quite correct. If your muffins are dry, they are also likely to be crumbly, which might be related to baking concerns.

You should utilize the temperature specified in the recipe, and you should also strive to keep to the prescribed baking time. There may be some exceptions to this, which will be discussed later, but following the recipe exactly is typically the best way to success.

Heating difficulties and overbaking will not be the most typical causes of muffins that are dry and crumbly. Even so, you need pay special attention to how you do things to ensure that you obtain the desired outcomes.

5 – Altitude Issues

Most people don’t consider it, but altitude may have an effect on how your muffins come out. Baking muffins in a high-altitude setting, such as Denver, will be different from baking in a low-altitude region.

The majority of recipes are created to provide satisfactory results when baked at sea level. If you’re baking above sea level, you may need to make some modifications to obtain the best results.

To compensate for altitude fluctuations, it may be necessary to make minor modifications to the quantity of flour used in your muffins. Temperature variations might also help you get better outcomes.

If you reside in a high-altitude area, it could be a good idea to look for a specialized recipe for high-altitude muffins. This will guarantee that you get everything correct and that your muffins come out moist.

Another thing to keep in mind while baking at high altitudes is to use brown sugar. By substituting brown sugar with granulated sugar, you could get excellent results.

Do Your Best

Reading the material above should give you a much better understanding of what causes muffins to be crumbly. It’s usually due to incorrect ingredient selection and a lack of fat.

Fortunately, if you know what to look for, you can easily turn things around. If your muffins have already come out dry and crumbly, you may choose to discard them, but you can get better results the next time.

To prevent difficulties, just be cautious while measuring out your components and use the correct sort of flour. You should have a pleasant experience as long as you do not use vegetable oil spread or diet margarine.

Muffins are unquestionably a delicious treat that the whole family will enjoy. You want them to come out delightfully every time, and it will be simpler to do so now that you know more about the frequent errors to avoid.


What causes crumbly muffins?

Wrapper for a margarine stick. Instead, put it into a dry (nested) measuring cup, then level with a spatula or the straight edge of a knife blade. Margarine or butter may have been measured improperly. Too little fat results in dry, crumbly muffins. Cut along the lines seen on the butter with care.

What prevents muffins from falling apart?

How do you prevent muffins from crumbling? Gluten is the culprit. Gluten, you see, is what keeps the world together for a baker.

Why are my muffins dry and dense?

4 teaspoon of baking soda. Too much leavening – If the mixture contains too much baking soda or powder, the muffins may rise briefly before collapsing. As a result, they grow thick. You just need 1 teaspoon of baking powder or 1 teaspoon of baking soda for every cup of flour.

How do you fix muffins that are too dry?

According to LiveStrong, you may rescue slightly overbaked goods by putting back in some moisture. Just brush the tops of your muffins with a little milk before they cool fully. If you’ve gone too far, try heating your muffins when you’re ready to eat them.

What is the most common mistake when making muffins?

To Avoid Common Muffin Making Errors
The batter was over-mixed.
Filling the muffin tin to the brim.
Leave the muffins in the pan once they’ve finished baking.
Berries, nuts, and chocolate chips settle to the bottom of the container.
Mar 12, 2019

What consistency should muffin batter be?

Depending on the components, the mixture will be watery (like thin cake batter) to quite thick (like drop-cookie dough). In general, the thinner the batter, the lighter the cooked muffins will be. So don’t be scared to use a thick, gloppy mixture in your baking.

How do you make baked goods less crumbly?

In modest quantities, add additional liquid components. Milk, egg yolks or whites, vanilla essence, or even a teaspoon of water may help wet the dough and make the cookies less crumbly. A little amount of liquid, such as milk, may also help your cookies spread in the oven, resulting in a crisper cookie.

How do you make cupcakes less crumbly?

Typically, you may disguise the dryness of a cupcake by adding more frosting than usual, or by choosing a frosting with a more liquid texture, since this will offset the dry cake element of the cupcake.

How can I improve the texture of my muffins?

Ingredients should be used at room temperature.

It may also produce thick muffins rather than light and fluffy muffins. Bring the eggs, milk, and butter to room temperature before using them; otherwise, they may take longer to break down and incorporate, increasing the danger of over-mixing the batter.

Do muffins go dry to wet or wet to dry?

Muffin Mixing Method: Allow for Lumpiness

Separately, the dry and wet components are combined, and then the wet ingredients are added to the dry.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *