Why Are My Scones So Difficult? (4 Common Causes)

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Scones are delicious for a variety of reasons, but many people prefer them with coffee or tea. They’re delicious pastries that go nicely with hot drinks.

Of course, if you don’t drink coffee or tea, you may just eat them as snacks. You’ve probably had scones from a variety of bakeries in the past.

You could even have family members who bake delectable handmade scones. If you were inspired to make your own scones because of this, you may have ended yourself here.

While making scones for the first time, inexperienced bakers often make blunders. Are your scones turning out considerably tougher than you expected?

Continue reading to see why scones may come out tougher than normal. You’ll also learn about other common scones-making blunders and how to prevent them.

1 – Working the Dough Too Much

Working the dough is the most typical reason why individuals make scones that are excessively firm. To get things to come out right, you have to work the dough, but many beginning bakers go crazy.

If you work the dough too much, the scones will be considerably harder than usual. Flaky and simple to eat, the perfect scone will be flaky and easy to eat.

Working the dough with a lighter touch is one approach to attempt to solve this issue. You must learn how to work the dough just enough to bring it together, and you should stop when it does.

When you haven’t cooked scones in a long time, it may take some practice to get it properly. If you have an experienced person to learn from, you might attempt to observe what they do to determine how much you need to work the dough.

Keep in mind that the dough will still have some bumps and lumps after you’ve finished working it. It is not necessary to work the dough until it is entirely smooth.

2 – Using Too Much Milk

Using too much milk might result in rough scones as well. While baking scones, some individuals make the mistake of adding more milk or buttermilk than necessary.

To make flaky and excellent scones, you must be cautious with the amount of milk you use. You just need a little amount to get the dough to stay together correctly.

It’s also a good idea to attempt to use low-fat milk for this procedure. If you used the appropriate quantity of milk or buttermilk, the dough should be a bit crumbly.

If you use more than necessary, the scones will most likely be hard. This makes them less appealing to consume, and you’re unlikely to complete them.

3 – You Should Use Cold Ingredients

Scones have been observed to have complications when utilizing room-temperature components. While baking scones, it’s critical to keep the dough cool so that the butter you’re using doesn’t melt.

If you use cold ingredients, the butter will be less likely to melt. This includes utilizing cold eggs, milk, and other components.

Remember to do this so that you may make scones that are perfectly baked. It’s conceivable that using warmer ingredients is one of the reasons your scones aren’t coming out right.

Another useful suggestion is to refrigerate the dough before beginning to bake. This reduces the likelihood of the butter melting before the scones complete baking.

To accomplish this, just cut the scones into wedges and lay them on a baking pan. As you wait for the oven to heat up to the proper temperature, place them in the refrigerator.

This will give you ample time to refrigerate the dough before you begin. It is worthwhile to spend the additional effort on this.

4 – Use Pastry Flour

Utilizing pastry flour might be the secret weapon to making light, fluffy scones. Most individuals end up utilizing ordinary flours like all-purpose flour since that’s what they have on hand.

Although using all-purpose flour may be OK for making scones, it is not always desirable. This is because all-purpose flour has more protein than many other varieties of flour.

You might substitute pastry flour, which is low in protein. Using this sort of flour keeps the scones from becoming overly thick.

Several scone recipes may call for a combination of two distinct flour kinds. To produce the dough, for example, you could be requested to combine all-purpose flour and cake flour.

Look for a straightforward method that will enable you to bake scones using pastry flour. It will most likely assist you in obtaining the desired outcomes.

Remember That Baking Scones Ahead of Time Makes Things Easier

Lastly, remember that creating scones ahead of time will make your life much simpler. In general, you want to serve scones when you have folks around for lunch or when you meet together with pals for coffee.

It is not always simple to prepare scones in time for these gatherings unless you plan ahead of time. You don’t want to hurry preparing scones since you’ll be more likely to make errors.

Alternatively, you may make the dough ahead of time and bake the scones right before your guests come. Scones are best served hot and fresh, but you may prepare ahead of time so that everything is ready for you.

Prepare your dough and mold it into whichever form you like. The dough should then be refrigerated overnight so that it is ready to bake when the time comes.

This means you just have to worry about getting the dough into the oven at the correct temperature. It relieves stress and enables you to enjoy a wonderful breakfast with some of your closest friends.

Final Thoughts

The tips above should make it much simpler to prepare soft and delectable scones. When done correctly, these pastries should be light and fluffy.

Just try to avoid the most typical errors that individuals make. Try not to overwork the dough since this will frequently result in scones that are considerably harder than usual.

Use cold ingredients and refrigerate the dough before baking the scones. That will keep the butter from melting too quickly.

You should also think about the sort of flour you’re using. To make the lightest scones possible, use pastry flour instead of all-purpose flour.

Understanding all of this will make making scones much simpler. You should get good results, and you’ll be happy to welcome guests around to sample what you’ve cooked.


What causes scones to be hard?

Overworking the dough: If you overwork the dough, your scones will be harsh and chewy instead of the desirable light and crumbly quality. The idea is to massage the dough lightly and just until it barely comes together.

How do you fix hard scones?

Place the scones in the microwave with a small glass of water, since the water will rehydrate the scones without drying them out. Thanks! We appreciate your feedback.

What makes scones not to be soft?

The dough was overworked.

Overworking the dough will result in harsh and chewy scones rather than light and fluffy scones. The idea is to massage the dough with a delicate touch until it barely comes together. Follow this advice: Anticipate lumps and bumps in your dough; when it just comes together, it’s ready to use.

Why are my scones heavy and dense?

My scones are thick, hefty, and lack volume.

You may have used too little rising agent or handled the dough too much before baking. The oven might have been too cold.

What is the secret of making good scones?

The less you knead the mixture, the less the gluten will tighten, resulting in scones that are loose and crumbly rather than tight and bouncy. Make certain that you filter the flour and baking powder into the mixing basin. This implies the two will be well blended, giving you a higher likelihood of an equal increase.

Why are my scones flat and hard?

Flat scones that spread when cooked are frequently the result of excessively soft batter or an overheated oven. A dark hue might be generated by too much sugar or a hot oven. Heavy, thick scones might be produced by poor flour, overworked dough, or expired leveling agents.

Are scones supposed to be hard or soft?

Scones should be crusty on the exterior and soft and moist on the interior. They should not be crumbly or dried.

Are scones supposed to be dry and hard?

A scone should not be crumbly like a biscuit.

Of course, there may be layers, but they should be crumbly. A scone is somewhat drier than a biscuit, but not at all dry when done properly. After all, scones are meant to be enjoyed with a hot beverage of your choosing. Add some clotted cream, butter, or jam.

Why do my scones turn out like rock cakes?

This may occur if you use too much butter. These will be more like cookies if you double the quantity of butter in our recipe (we tested it for you). Thus, try to cut down on the butter. Remember that after working the fat into the flour, the mixture should have a crumbly texture.

Which flour is best for scones?

For a higher-rising scone that retains its form well in and out of the oven, use all-purpose flour. Substitute cake flour for all-purpose flour to produce more delicate, lower-rising, cake-like scones. Decrease the liquid by 1 to 2 teaspoons in the recipe, using just enough to bring the dough together.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *