Why are the tops of my muffins sticky?

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Nothing like the delectable fragrance of freshly made muffins, particularly first thing in the morning. These delightful sweets are guaranteed to start your family’s day off properly or make a delicious snack.

As you attempt to take a piece of your muffin, you’ll be disappointed to find that the tops have gone sticky and disgusting.

This might have occurred for a number of reasons. Let’s look at a few quick remedies to avoid sticky, soggy muffin tops in the future.

Make Sure You Follow Your Recipe Exactly

Baking is an exact science, which means you must carefully follow all instructions. Otherwise, the chemical reactions that take place during the mixing and baking processes may not function effectively, resulting in unsatisfactory outcomes.

This starts with your mise en place, or preparation. All ingredients should be measured properly, either using a food scale or precise measuring cups.

Before you begin cooking, go through the whole recipe to ensure you have all of the necessary materials and equipment. Check up any words that are unclear to you or that you are unsure about.

Take care not to overmix your muffins! Overmixing might result in poor baking and a sticky top because it releases too much gluten when combining dry and wet ingredients; your batter should have some lumps.

Calibrate or Adjust Your Oven

Many people are unaware that home ovens are usually inaccurate, which means that the interior temperature does not correspond to the temperature that the oven is measuring. A low oven temperature, in particular, may cause excessively wet, sticky muffin tops.

The simplest solution is to get a basic oven thermometer. Check it before putting anything in the oven and adjust the temperature if needed.

There are other methods for recalibration of your oven’s internal thermometer, which is particularly important if it is inaccurate by more than a few degrees. To learn more, see your owner’s handbook or search up the make and model of your oven online.

Of course, there are alternatives to using an oven to prepare muffins.

Storing Your Muffins

One of the most prevalent reasons of sticky, soggy muffin tops is improper storage. They may seem beautiful when they come out of the oven, but they will swiftly change.

This is because the moisture within baked products migrates and finally evaporates as they age. If the muffins are stored in an airtight container, the moisture has nowhere to go and sits on the top, leaving them sticky and mushy.

At the same time, keeping them in an airtight container is essential for retaining freshness in other ways. So don’t worry, you don’t have to give up fresh muffins for a sticky top.

First and foremost Although a freshly baked muffin is delicious, it cannot be stored in that state. You must totally chill your muffins before storing them; otherwise, the heat will be retained within the container, causing even more moisture.

Cool your muffins on a wire rack. This allows cold air to flow all around them, eliminating soggy bottoms and retaining extra moisture.

Line the airtight container with paper towels before placing the muffins inside. Now for the truly cool trick! Put a few saltine crackers in the container with the muffins to absorb excess moisture and keep the muffins from getting sticky.

Close the container with a layer of paper towels on top of the muffins to absorb any extra moisture. Avoid opening and shutting it more than is absolutely required.

Try a Technique to Make Them Crispy

Even the greatest baking and storing practices, especially if you live in a humid region, may not be enough to keep your muffin tops crispy. There are a few additional things you can do to make your own crispy muffin top.

You may prepare a crunchy topping to go on top of the muffins. This topping is usually made with brown sugar.

Just sprinkle the topping over the muffin dough in the muffin pans; it will solidify during baking.

You may even create only the muffin tops and leave out the body of the muffin, giving you more control over how the tops turn out. All you need is a muffin top tray.

Try a New Recipe

If all else fails, you may always try a new recipe. There are several muffin recipes available in cookbooks and on the Internet.

A good rule of thumb to follow when selecting a recipe is that a dish that has more sugar than flour will surely get sticky, if not immediately, then later. Search for a recipe that is low in sugar.

Additionally, search for a recipe that calls for butter rather than other types of fat (like oils). This Chocolate Chip Muffin recipe contains butter and more than twice as much flour as sugar.

Try these recipes for Crunchy-Topped Blueberry Muffins and Orange Chocolate Muffins.

Embrace the Stickiness!

We just said that if all else fails, you may try a fresh recipe, but there is one more option: embrace the stickiness!

Even if it isn’t your favorite flavor, some individuals appreciate a sticky muffin. The wet surface sometimes makes them taste more like a sweet pastry than a breakfast grain.

Instead, you may take advantage of the stickiness to glue decorations to make them even more beautiful. Search for sprinkles or other similar products at your local supermarket or craft shop; they will not modify the taste of the muffins, but will offer an appealing visual.

Don’t Be Discouraged!

Baking is unlike cooking in that it is a precise technique that takes a long time to master.

Don’t get dismayed if your baked goods don’t come out perfectly; simply keep baking! Odds are, everything you’ve created will still taste delicious and make your family members happy, and isn’t that the ultimate goal?


Why are the tops of my muffins sticky?

A sugar and water interaction produces sticky cake and cupcake tops. Sugars are hygroscopic, which means they absorb water. Sugars aid in the preservation of a moist and soft crumb in baked foods. Sugar on the exposed tops, on the other hand, will absorb water from the humid air, resulting in a moist or sticky top.

How do you make cupcake tops not sticky?

The top of the cupcakes is sticky.

To address this issue, spread powdered sugar and ground cinnamon on top of each cupcake to absorb moisture and garnish with red fruits.

How do you keep muffins from getting moist on top?

Line an airtight container with paper towels and arrange the muffins in a single layer on top. Don’t forget to include some saltines to absorb moisture! Put paper towels on top of the muffins to absorb any excess liquid. Close the container with an airtight cover.

Why are my muffins too wet?

Steamed Till Soggy

Soggy bottoms are typically created by keeping muffins in their pans for too long when using recipes without heavy or juicy add-ins. This is a concern because it traps steam. Baked foods are naturally quite hot when they come out of the oven, and internal steam must escape as they cool.

Why are my muffins dense and gummy?

4 teaspoon of baking soda. Too much leavening – If the mixture contains too much baking soda or powder, the muffins may rise briefly before collapsing. As a result, they grow thick. You just need 1 teaspoon of baking powder or 1 teaspoon of baking soda for every cup of flour.

Are cupcakes supposed to be sticky on top?

If cupcakes get sticky on top after cooling, it is usually because they were kept in an airtight container before they were entirely cold, causing condensation to develop, or because they were cooked and chilled in a humid climate.

Why do my cupcakes have a gummy texture?

If your cupcakes have a gummy feel despite following a tried-and-true recipe, you most likely overmixed the batter. Unless otherwise specified in the recipe, simply mix until the ingredients are barely blended. Overmixing the batter might result in gummy cupcakes.

How do you make cupcakes stay flat on top?

Three-quarters of the way up.
Reduce the temperature of your oven; we bake at 170°C (non-fan) or 150°C (fan).
Additional information…•Mar 16, 2017
Top Flat Top Cupcake Tips
Don’t overwork your combination.
Don’t overfill your cupcake cases; your cupcakes will rise, so load 2 cases if you want your cupcakes to come to just beneath the top of the cases.

Should I store muffins in the fridge or cupboard?

Refrigerator: Generally, muffins should not be refrigerated. But, if your muffins are savory in nature and contain cheeses or meats in the recipe, keep them in the fridge for up to six days.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *