Why do the tops of my brownies crack?

8 Min Read
Rate this post

Brownies are a popular choice for dessert whether preparing for a bake sale, potluck, or other big events. They’re also a wonderful pick-me-up for a lone outing.

Brownies are popular because they are simple to prepare in comparison to many other sweets, even if they are made from scratch rather than from a box. Its fudgy, chocolate flavor is well-known and brings back fond memories for many individuals.

Yet, just though brownies are simple to prepare does not rule out the possibility of anything going wrong throughout the process. Brownies may go wrong in a variety of ways, from overbaking to improper batter mixing.

A cracked top is one of the most frequent brownie-baking mistakes. Little cracks are normal in all brownie batches, but major fissures may cause the whole tray to collapse and lose texture. Here are a few reasons why your brownies could be breaking and how to avoid it.

Basic Brownie Technique

Brownies are a reasonably straightforward treat to create when compared to layer cakes and intricate pastry. There are several recipes available online for both standard brownies and brownies with unusual taste combinations, such as this one.

The majority of brownies are baked with a foundation of chocolate, butter, eggs, sugar, and flour. First, the butter and sugar are combined.

The remaining ingredients are then gently folded in. Lastly, the brownies are cooked for a little more than half an hour at a medium temperature.

Brownies are simpler to prepare than other desserts since they don’t involve kneading or even more than one dish. Nonetheless, errors may still be made throughout the procedure, resulting in cracks on the tops of the brownies.

Brownie Cracks—Good or Bad?

Brownies can be divisive for such a simple dish. Individuals sometimes disagree on the ideal technique to cook brownies; some prefer fudgy brownies to cakey ones, while others prefer crispy edge pieces to gooey centers.

Some people believe that when the top of a brownie cracks, it breaks apart the soft, fudgy texture. Instead of a consistent softness, the brownies now have a crunch on top.

Some individuals enjoy cracked-top brownies because they add texture and flair to standard brownies. There are even recipes available to aid in the development of a touch of a flaky top.

Most brownies will have a crack or two on top since it is a natural aspect of baking, no matter how hard you try to avoid them. Even those who like a crusty brownie will concede that too many cracks lead the brownie to collapse in the centre.

How Cracks Form in Brownies

A few cracks are usual when the brownie mixture dries up and transforms into cooked brownies. Too many cracks, on the other hand, indicate that something went wrong during the mixing or baking process.

A crackly top is only an annoyance that may disrupt the texture uniformity of a brownie. When there are too many cracks, the brownie batter collapses and the structural integrity of the dessert is compromised.

Here are a few reasons why your brownie batter is breaking or collapsing.

Overbeating the Mixture

An over-beaten mixture is one of the most prevalent causes of cracked tops on brownies. This normally occurs when the eggs are mixed with the sugar and butter.

Not only does beating a combination integrate the components, but it also adds air to the batter. This is great when preparing things like meringues or cake batter, but it is not ideal while baking brownies.

As the batter is placed in the oven, the air bubbles expand because to the heat. After being shocked by cold air, the air bubbles burst and produce fractures as they come out of the oven.

The more air bubbles there are in your batter, the more fractures will occur when they collapse. While cooking brownies, your objective is to keep air bubbles at bay.

Baking Time

As brownies bake, the liquid batter dries out and solidifies. It is usual for a few cracks to appear on the surface as this process proceeds.

When they are left in the oven for too long, additional cracks occur, but they are the least of your troubles.

Brownies lose their delicate, creamy texture when they are overbaked. They become flaky and dry.

Most recipes instruct you to remove brownies from the oven after you observe a few cracks. Following this rule of thumb can help you avoid drying out and cracking your brownies.

Preventing Cracks in Your Brownies

If you are careful not to overbake your brownies, the most likely cause of the breaking is that you are accidently overmixing the mixture. While creaming together sugar and butter, you may combine as much as you like, but when you add eggs, air bubbles are more likely to develop.

If you are concerned about overmixing the eggs, one solution is to beat the eggs together in a separate bowl. You may need to do a few more dishes, but this way the yolks will be broken without overmixing the batter.

After all of your ingredients are incorporated in the same bowl, just mix until there are no dry spots of flour visible.

Achieving Smooth Brownies, Every Time

Brownies are such a basic dish that every error, even a slight crack, stands out. Some individuals enjoy a crackly brownie top, while others prefer a smooth brownie experience.

If you don’t want flakiness in your brownies, stir the mixture as little as possible and don’t overbake them. The texture will then be excellent!


How do you cut brownies without cracking the top?

To cut the brownie in half, gently coat both sides of the blade with cooking spray and make one strong, confident swipe over the width of the brownie. Clean the blade clean, spray the blade, and cut, continuing the wiping and spraying procedure until the whole brownie is sliced up.

Why doesn’t my brownies have a crust on top?

“How much you beat the mixture after the eggs are added determines whether brownies have a crust on top.” The more you beat, the thicker the crust. A dramatic crust may be obtained by aggressively beating the mixture using a mixer.

Are brownies done when they crack?

Examine the surface for cracks.

Moisture evaporates while brownies cook, thus a few cracks indicate that the brownies are baked but still wet in the middle. Check the gloss of the surface as well—cake brownies will seem matte or dry rather than moist and shiny.

Should I beat my eggs for brownies?

Our response

The eggs and sugar should be beaten just enough to break them up and dissolve the sugar somewhat. This may be done by hand using just a fork. It is not necessary to whisk the eggs and sugar until they have risen in volume, since this might introduce too much air into the brownies, making them overly cake-like.

How thick should brownie batter be?

It all depends on your own tastes and the recipe. If you want your brownies cakey, you’ll probably prefer a thinner batter. If you like a fudgier texture, add a bit more milk (or water) to make it thicker.

What happens if you don t grease a pan before baking brownies?

One of the most critical tasks in baking is to grease the pan. If you don’t know how to oil a pan, baked items will cling to it. Grease the pan before baking to prevent the brownies from sticking. It also makes cleaning up after cooking simpler since food does not adhere to it.

What do overcooked brownies look like?

Chocolate Brownies

This indicates that it is overdone, dry, and crumbly. Instead, you want to see some brown crumbs on the toothpick. The crumbs should be moist but not soggy. If the toothpick comes out with wet, goopy batter stuck to it, the cake need longer baking time.

Should you let brownies sit before cutting them?

Let your brownies to cool fully to room temperature. Since brownies firm and set up as they cool, cutting into them too soon might result in brownie squares that break apart or become a mess very fast.

What temperature should brownies be when done?

Brownies and bars have a similar consistency to thick sweetbreads and may be baked at the same temperature. Temperature should be between 180°F (82°C) and 190°F (88°C) for moist fudgy brownies. What exactly is this? Bake until the internal temperature of the cake-like brownies reaches 210°F (99°C).

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *