Why Does My Cake Taste Like Cornbread?

10 Min Read
5/5 - (1 vote)

If you’ve just finished baking a cake and discover that it has the texture and flavor of cornmeal, it might be a big letdown. Baking is difficult, and there is no way to know what the outcome will be. However, if you are aware of what contributes to the cornbread flavor, you will be able to eliminate it the next time you make a cake.

The question is, why does my cake have the flavor of cornbread?

It’s possible that you’re using old ingredients, fumbling with the proportions, or using flour that’s gone stale. The following are all of the factors that contribute to cakes having the flavor of cornbread.

1 – You Didn’t Beat the Batter Well

It is imperative that you give the batter a thorough beating in the beginning so that it may rise and develop the sugary and airy consistency that you want. If you don’t give it a good beating, the consistency will be thick since there won’t be enough air incorporated into it.

In this instance, it may have the flavor of cornmeal due to the fact that it is not as fluffy as cakes should be.

It is recommended that you invest in an electric handheld mixer if you have limited dexterity in your hands. In less than two minutes, it will properly and thoroughly mix the batter. There is also the option of using a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment.

Always check to see that the batter has enough air circulation throughout it. Instead of being thick and dense, it should have a creamy texture. In addition, there shouldn’t be any residues of sugar everywhere.

2 – You Beat the Batter Too Hard

The overbeating of the batter is just as detrimental as the underbeating of it. When you mix it for longer than is required, the components will give out gluten that is sticky.

Your cake will not only end up tasting more like cornbread as a result of this addition, but its consistency will also become more similar to that of cornbread.

If you are going to use an electric mixer, be sure that you do not let it run for an excessive amount of time. You’ll be able to turn it off and go on with the recipe after there are no more streaks of sugar and flour in the mixture.

3 – You’re Using Unbleached Flour

You may not understand the difference between bleached and unbleached flour if you are just starting out in the world of baking. Flour that has been bleached is white in color, has a grain that is very fine, and its consistency is often smooth when held in the hands.

On the other hand, unbleached flour has a more uneven consistency, and its granules are often more compact. Additionally, its color will tend more toward an off-white hue.

If you create your cake using unbleached flour, it may have the flavor of cornbread since unbleached flour isn’t self-rising as bleached flour is. When you create a cake from scratch in the future, it is recommended that you use all-purpose flour.

4 – You Didn’t Add Enough Sugar

There is a good probability that your cake will not have the flavor of a cake if it does not have enough sugar in it. Sugar is an essential component of baked products and is mostly responsible for the sweetness that it imparts to the finished product. If, on the other hand, biting into the cake feels more like biting into a piece of cornbread, it’s possible that you did not add enough sugar.

Make sure that you add at least the quantity of sugar that is advised for the recipe you are following, if not more. When you beat the batter, you need to make sure that the sugar is completely dissolved in it. In the event that this does not occur, the cake will have a grainy consistency as a result of the undissolved sugar pieces.

5 – You Added Cornstarch Accidently

Things may go wrong, and there is no recipe that is completely risk-free. You may, for instance, inadvertently use corn starch instead of baking powder due to the similarities between the two in terms of their consistency and texture.

In this scenario, the flavor of the cake will be similar to that of cornbread, and the texture will be far denser than you would anticipate due to the absence of baking powder.

It’s probably a good idea to put labels on your powder jars right now if you don’t already have them. You won’t make the mistake of using corn starch in place of baking powder this way.

6 – You’re Not Storing Your Ingredients Right

If the flour has been stored in the cupboard for an excessive amount of time, you may have inadvertently placed it next to an unopened box of cornmeal. If this occurs, the cake will most likely wind up smelling like cornbread, which will be a result of the flour absorbing the odor.

The same is true if you use butter that has been lying about for a while or eggs that have been stored in your refrigerator for many weeks.

Even if you follow all of the instructions to a T, you may not get the results you were hoping for if the ingredients aren’t fresh. Always be sure to keep the flour in a location that is apart from anything that might produce a smell.

7 – Your Baking Powder Is Expired

Baking powder is an important component of the cake you’ve made. In the event that it has gone bad or has beyond its expiration date, the cake will not live up to your standards. The same is true for baking soda, which, after it has beyond its expiration date, emits an unpleasant flavor.

Before you begin baking, check that all of the ingredients are still in good condition, as was just indicated. Your cake’s flavor may be greatly altered by even the smallest of its components, regardless of how little they may seem.

8 – You’re Using Stale Flour

If an ingredient is left out for an extended period of time without being utilized, it runs the risk of becoming stale. It’s possible that if you don’t have any new flour, you’ll convince yourself that it’s OK to use that old bag that’s been lying in your cupboard for years. On the other hand, this is probably the reason why the flavor of your cake isn’t quite right.

Flour that has been sitting about for a while will often have a faint odor. If you bake a cake using it, the finished product won’t have the same crisp and sugary flavor that you’re accustomed to getting from baked goods. It is also possible that it will not mix properly with the batter mixture, which will result in a cake that is heavy and lacks a fluffy texture.

9 – Your Flour Has Residual Cornmeal

If you get your flour from a place that is not reliable, there is a possibility that it contains some leftover cornmeal.

If this is the case, the cake will always have the flavor of cornmeal, whatever the efforts you make to prevent this from happening.

Ensure that you get your flour from a reliable retailer at all times. You may even give it a whiff to be absolutely certain that it does not contain any cornmeal residue.

10 – You’re Messing With The Measurements

A recipe should always be followed exactly. You may anticipate a difference in flavor if you choose to tamper with the measures or use an excessive number of additives in comparison to what is required.

Changing the proportions of the components in the cake will undoubtedly result in a difference in flavor, even if the cake does not always taste like cornbread.

When not supplied in the appropriate quantities, ingredients like flour and additives, in particular, have the potential to muddle the flavor. Always make an effort to stick to a recipe rather than devising your own proportions instead.

11 – You’re Baking at a High Temperature

The texture of the cake may be greatly affected by the baking temperature. If you bake the cake at a temperature that is higher than what is required, there is a good probability that the outside may become dry.

The top surface will bake more quickly than the inside of it. As a result, as you wait for the inside to bake, the outside will turn out to be dry. It is possible that the flavor may not be identical to that of cornbread, but the consistency will be more comparable.

Because of this, it is quite important to regulate the temperature in accordance with the components that you are using. Do not make the mistake of attempting to adjust the temperature on your own if you are working from a recipe. To get the outcome you want, just follow the instructions in the correct order.


Why does cake taste floury?

If you can detect the flavor of raw flour in the cake, it’s possible that it hasn’t been cooked for long enough. It’s possible that the temperature in your oven is set too low. Obtain a thermometer for the oven, and then examine its temperature to see if it is at the appropriate level. If it isn’t, you may re-calibrate it by following the instructions provided by the manufacturer.

Why did my cake come out like a pancake?

It’s possible that you overbeat the components in your cake, which results in it having a flat appearance. When you overmix the ingredients, you might end up with a thick batter that does not rise as well as it otherwise would. A cake that is flat might also be the result of improperly proportioned baking powder (either too much or too little).

Why does my cake have the texture of bread?

Because the gluten in wheat is activated when there is excessive mixing of it, a cake may become rubbery when it is overmixed. It results in a firm texture in cakes, rather than the wonderful, soft, and spongy feel that we often associate with a nice cake. And the overmixing is often brought on by an improper method of creaming together butter and sugar.

Why does my cake have a weird taste?

When people bake, one of the most frequent mistakes they make is adding an excessive amount of baking soda or baking powder in their recipes. Be aware that using an excessive amount of baking soda or baking powder in cakes will not only result in a metallic and bitter flavor, but it will also cause a significant amount of mess in the oven since the cake will rise much higher than expected.

How do you get rid of floury taste?

When you are nearly done making the gravy, if it has the flavor of flour, crank up the heat to keep it at a quick simmer for several minutes. After that, you may thin it again with more stock or water if it is too thick. It is expected that a fat separator would solve this issue.

Final Thoughts

The question is, why does my cake have the flavor of cornbread?

There is a good chance that you are following the directions for the recipe incorrectly. It’s possible that you’ve substituted corn starch for baking powder, that you’re mixing the mixture too vigorously, or that you’re not pounding it enough. It’s also possible that the flour you’re using is stale or that it contains cornmeal leftovers. There is no way around the fact that the cake won’t come out as well as you want it to.

To prevent this from happening, you should verify that each of the elements is in its most recent iteration. In addition to that, you shouldn’t try to change the measures in any way. To get the effect you want, be sure to strictly adhere to the recipe.

You might also like