Why Is My French Toast Eggy? (6 Common Reasons)

7 Min Read
Rate this post

French toast is one of the most popular morning meals. It’s not something most people eat every day, but it’s something they look forward to on special occasions.

Making French toast at home for your family is enjoyable. It’s also not that difficult to get it to come out good in general.

However, you may sometimes make blunders while doing so. For example, your French toast may come out a little eggy.

Why does French toast sometimes come out eggy? What can you do to avoid this happening?

Continue reading to learn all you need to know. It will make making tasty French toast simpler in the future.

1 – Make Sure You’re Following the Recipe

Why Is My French Toast Eggy? (6 Common Reasons)

The first thing to remember is to follow the recipe exactly. To prepare French toast, most recipes will instruct you to use just egg yolks or egg whites.

Using whole eggs may provide very different outcomes. This might be causing your French toast to have an eggy flavor that you dislike.

Read the recipe carefully to ensure you’re using the correct ingredients. You should not hurry the procedure since errors are possible.

Too many egg whites or incorrect substances might lead to difficulties. Take it slowly and make sure you’re following the instructions exactly.

2 – Egg Whites

Egg whites are responsible for the eggy flavor you’re tasting in your French toast. If you don’t like eggy French toast, you could use egg yolks instead.

Because egg whites contain sulfur compounds, they provide an eggy flavor to French toast. Because egg yolks varies, you should be able to get a variety of effects.

Perhaps finding a recipe that explicitly calls for egg yolks would be beneficial. This will help you to avoid the eggy flavor to the greatest extent feasible.

When cooking French toast, you should get some kind of eggy flavor. It’s not meant to be very strong, but there might be things you’re doing that are exacerbating the situation.

You’ll learn about some things you could be doing incorrectly farther down. It will be simpler to prepare good French toast if you can flip things around.

3 – Not Cooking the French Toast Long Enough

It’s also possible that the French toast was undercooked. Typically, recipes call for cooking the French toast on both sides for around four minutes.

You’re supposed to use medium heat, and you want to make sure everything cooks evenly. Of course, you don’t want your French toast to burn.

As a result, you must pay close attention to what you are doing. French toast may be cooked in a variety of ways, including on a griddle.

Just be cautious to do things correctly. You want to cook everything for a long enough time to avoid scorching the bread.

Because it includes sugar, French toast is prone to burning. If you’re not cautious, the sugar will caramelize and burn, so keep an eye on what you’re doing.

4 – Strain the Egg Mixture

It’s also a good idea to strain the egg mixture. Before soaking your bread in the egg mixture, strain it.

What is the point of doing this? If you don’t, your French toast may end up with egg chunks.

You want the custard on the French toast, but not the egg lumps. This may be avoided by straining the egg mixture.

It takes very little time to strain the egg mixture. Simply remember to do this before soaking the bread for optimum results.

5 – You’re Not Soaking the Bread Long Enough

It’s possible you’re not soaking the bread long enough. When creating French toast, you should create an egg mixture.

You’ll need this egg mixture to soak the bread in. Many individuals make the mistake of dipping the bread in the egg mixture and then proceeding to the next step.

You’re not meant to do stuff like this. To create French toast, soak the bread in the egg mixture for several minutes.

It is recommended that you soak the bread in the egg mixture for at least fifteen minutes. If you’re using thick bread, soak it for up to twenty minutes.

This enables the egg mixture to fully soak into the bread, ensuring that the taste is consistent across the slice of bread. If you don’t do this, the eggy flavor may be more prominent on the bread’s outside edges.

Take your time and soak your bread before cooking it. It doesn’t take long, and it’s a vital step in the process.

6 – You’re Not Using the Right Type of Bread

Another possible issue is using the incorrect kind of bread. If you use extremely thin bread, making French toast will be difficult.

Thin sandwich bread from the grocery store may not be the greatest option here. You’d get greater results if you used brioche bread.

Thick pieces of Texas toast or a French baguette may also be used. Just be sure to choose thick bread that will absorb the egg mixture adequately.

Thin bread might come out odd. It’s possible that’s why your French toast has an eggy flavor you don’t like.

So go out and get some bread that is recognized for making wonderful French toast. This will provide you with a much better overall experience.

Final Thoughts

You should now have a better understanding of what you need to do to prepare French toast. If you follow the tips above, your French toast will be less likely to be eggy.

Of course, some folks just dislike the flavor of French toast. It’s conceivable that you don’t like the custard.

In this scenario, you may change the flavor by adding additional sweetness to mask the typical custard flavor. For people who dislike the flavor of custard, just eating French toast with maple syrup and powdered sugar might make it taste nice.


Why does my French toast come out eggy?

You’re using too much milk or not enough egg yolks: The custard foundation that gives French toast its soft richness is made up of eggs and milk, but if the proportions are incorrect, you’ll end up with undercooked slices with an unpleasantly flavorful “scrambled eggs” taste.

What is the most common mistake in making French toast?

The Top 7 French Toast Cooking Mistakes
Excessive dairy and sugar in the custard. Don’t overdo it on the dairy.
The custard was not fully mixed.
Choosing the wrong bread.
Bread that has not been properly soaked.
Using too much or not enough heat.
The pan was not preheated.
Using just butter.

Is eggy bread soggy?

If there is too much, the egg will not cook, resulting in soggy bread. Whisk the mixture well until the milk, eggs, and spices (if used) are fully incorporated. Use somewhat stale bread – Fresh bread absorbs the mixture too rapidly, resulting in too soft eggy bread.

Is French toast better on high or low heat?

Aim for medium-low heat so that the interior can cook while the exterior is golden-brown and caramelized. Follow this advice: Before cooking the French toast, heat your griddle or frying pan to medium-low to ensure it’s ideally done on both the outside and the interior.

Why do I always mess up my French toast?

There are a few typical blunders that may wreak havoc on your french toast. You don’t want to overheat your griddle because the outsides will burn and the interior will be mushy. You don’t want to overdo it on the milk. If you want non-soggy toast, your batter should be more egg-y than milk-y.

Should French toast have more eggs or milk?

4 cup milk and one egg per two-slice serving—use just the yolks of some or all of the eggs to prevent the “scrambled” flavour.A good starting point is 1

How long should bread soak for French toast?

Allow your bread to soak up the sweet, eggy sauce for 15 to 20 minutes to produce that delightfully gooey, custard-like consistency within each slice of French toast.

When should I flip my French toast?

After a few minutes, check beneath a piece of bread to see whether the French toast has gotten golden and toasted. When it is done, turn each slice and continue to cook.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *