Why isn’t my toffee setting? (The two most common explanations)

8 Min Read
Rate this post

If you’ve ever made toffee, you’ll know that it doesn’t always set. This might be disappointing and stressful. But why doesn’t toffee set all the time? Is it possible to save a batch that simply won’t set?

Toffee should not be difficult to make. There are many methods for setting toffee, with the freezer process being the most effective. Inconsistent temperatures and inadequate cooking time are the two most typical causes of toffee not setting properly. Fortunately, a batch of unset toffee may be preserved.

If you want to know how to get your toffee to set properly every time, you’ve come to the perfect spot. Continue reading to learn all there is to know about producing the perfect toffee.

Why Does My Toffee Not Set?

Why Is My Toffee Not Setting? (The Two Most Common Reasons)

If your toffee isn’t setting or you want to avoid making any blunders, check out the list below of frequent faults people make while preparing toffee that may prevent the toffee from setting properly.

1 – Not Boiling the Toffee At an Appropriate Temperature

The toffee mixture will not set if it is not boiled on a high enough heat setting. Toffee should be boiled at a temperature of roughly 300 degrees Fahrenheit. The key to properly set toffee is the length of time it is boiled and the temperature it is heated to.

2 – Not Keeping the Toffee on the Heated Stove for Long Enough

Toffee that has been perfectly set should be easy to split in half. If the mixture does not have this hard texture, it was not cooked long enough before being removed from the fire. Toffee should be cooked for five minutes, although this is merely a suggestion.

The consistency of the mixture will alter when the toffee is sufficiently cooked. Use your best judgment to determine how long to keep the toffee simmering. This is a trial-and-error approach. It is better to let the toffee mixture to boil until it reaches the color of a brown bag.

How Long Does Toffee Take to Set?

Why Is My Toffee Not Setting? (The Two Most Common Reasons)

Toffee takes less time to set than other sweets and sweet desserts. Toffee may be prepared in three ways. The length of the procedure is determined on the technique you select to set your toffee.

Setting Toffee By Leaving It Out on the Counter

The first approach for setting toffee is to just leave it out on the counter overnight. It should take between eight and twelve hours for your toffee to set.

Setting Toffee By Placing It in the Fridge

The second option for setting your toffee is to put it in the refrigerator. This will considerably accelerate the setup procedure. If you employ this approach, the toffee will take around fifty minutes to cool and solidify.

Setting Toffee By Placing It in the Freezer

To speed up the setting time, put the toffee in the freezer. This is by far the most time-efficient technique of setup. By freezing the toffee, you may cut the setting time down to roughly twenty minutes.

How to Save Toffee That Did Not Set Correctly

If you’re reading this because you created a batch of toffee that didn’t set properly, don’t toss it out and start again! Instead, try one of these methods to get that batch to correctly set. It may need a little more of your time, but it is definitely worth it, and it is an excellent learning curve for novices.

  1. Place the toffee mixture in a big saucepan and cover with one and a half cups of water.
  2. Stir the toffee until it melts over low heat. This may dilute the flavor, but test it and add what you believe is lacking.
  3. Bring the toffee mixture to a boil over high heat. You must scrape the extra mixture off the edges of the saucepan while you stir during this phase. This will keep the mixture from burning and will guarantee a uniform distribution.
  4. Remove the saucepan from the heat after the consistency has thickened and the toffee has the color of a brown paper bag. Then, as directed by the recipe, let it cool before serving.

Tips for Making Tasty Toffee Every Time

If you’re bored of many botched batches of toffee, we’ve got you covered. The following suggestions will guarantee that your toffee is perfect every time.

Avoid Drastic Changes in Temperature

No matter how pressed for time you are, you should never attempt to speed up the boiling process by raising the temperature. This will cause the butter to separate from the sugar, ultimately ruining your toffee.

Stir the Mixture Constantly

While the toffee is still cooking on the stove, continue to stir it gently and carefully. This prevents the toffee (particularly the sugar) from burning. It is critical to stir gently without allowing the toffee mixture to remain idle in the saucepan for too long.

Avoid Making Toffee in Humid Climates

Your toffee will not set correctly if the humidity in the air is too high. It will be mushy and sloppy rather than solid and easily broken. Check the humidity levels before deciding to spend the day creating toffee.

Use a Candy Thermometer to Keep the Temperature Constant

Toffee has a boiling point of roughly 300 degrees Fahrenheit. Using a candy thermometer to test the temperature of the mixture can prevent you from accidently overcooking or undercooking your toffee. This is critical for your toffee to set properly.

Final Thoughts

Toffee may be a fun and satisfying treat to create, but the process of getting everything just right can be challenging and frustrating. You’ll have a delightful toffee treat for the entire family if you follow the instructions stated above and avoid making blunders.

Toffee requires two crucial ingredients: a consistent temperature and precise time.


Why did my toffee not harden?

What’s the deal with my soft toffee? You did not cook your toffee long enough if it does not have a firm texture (where you can break it in two). Again, the 5-minute time limit is just a guideline. Cook it until it resembles a brown bag.

What can I do with failed toffee?

There’s still hope if your toffee splits! Remove it from the heat and continue to whisk until the mixture comes back together, then gradually return it to the fire while stirring. You may also attempt to reassemble the toffee by whisking in a tablespoon or two of extremely hot water.

Why is my toffee liquidy?

This occurs when the liquid in the mixture evaporates too rapidly or when the mixture is stirred too quickly, causing the liquid and fat to separate. The addition of salt to the recipe seems to help stabilize the mixture. Use salted butter, or add 14 teaspoon of salt per stick of butter if using unsalted butter.

Do you stir toffee constantly?

Stir seldom (but not continuously) and prevent scraping down the pan’s sides. Toffee might separate if you stir it too rapidly or too often. Turn down the heat if the toffee is boiling or cooking too quickly so it doesn’t burn.

How do you fix toffee that didn’t set?

How to Restore Toffee That Didn’t Set Properly
Place the toffee mixture in a big saucepan and cover with one and a half cups of water.
Stir the toffee until it melts over low heat.
Bring the toffee mixture to a boil over high heat.

How do you fix toffee that is too soft?

Toffee’s texture may vary from soft, chewy caramel to shard-like brittle, depending on your preferences. Simple toffee recipes require sugar and water, but you may adjust the hardness degree by adding cream, butter, syrup, and condensed milk.

Why is my toffee chewy and not crunchy?

When there is too much moisture in toffee, it becomes chewy. Undercooking toffee may leave it wet and chewy, and recipes with a lot of dairy can also result in chewy toffee. Humidity may affect toffee production and cause stored toffees to soften and become sticky.

Do you put toffee in the fridge to set?

Refrigerate the toffee for 1 hour, or until it has hardened. Using the parchment paper, remove the firm toffee from the baking dish. Divide into pieces and keep in an airtight container.

How long does it take for toffee to reach hard crack stage?

Recipe for brittle toffee

Turn increase the heat and place the sugar thermometer in the pan after the sugar has dissolved. Bring to a boil, then continue to cook until your thermometer reads’soft crack’ (140°C). Be patient as this might take up to 30 minutes.

How do you solidify toffee?

You may add some cornstarch to the mixture along with some water. The toffee sauce must then be constantly stirred in order for it to thicken. You should be able to thicken the toffee sauce with a little more effort.

You might also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *